First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #1064?
haraggan: Talisman, Runebound, or neither?

MrPanic: Talisman
Fribian: Needer
puffinge: I've only played the former and I do like it.
adamw: Neither. Unless everyone else really wants to play. But even then I'd put on a bit of a fuss.
mrbeankc: Both are ok. Neither stands out for me very much.
moggle: Talisman
Felimid: Neither (except that I do have "Dragonquest"; I just haven't played it yet).
SaittaMicus: Talisman
skslotten: Just got Talisman and I really enjoy it.
KrisVerbeeck: for you?? both
cgund: Never played either.
The Unbeliever: 42
Polgara: neither
Hector Vortac: Thank you for the 'neither' option. However, I choose Talisman.
milhouse46: Talisman
dogzard: Talisman - at least I've played it before
sotc77: neither, hot maple syrup
DHEK: Neither. Because I've played neither.
aleo09: haven't played either.
Shannon Ferguson: talisman
Karlos the Jackal: *shudder* neither
dmomo: Never played
bigbadsteve: no opinion
ZombyDawg: Talisman, if it's up to me. Runebound if I want other people to play.
Glenn: talisman
wargamer66: Neither. Need the definitive adventure game someday.
vetinari7878: I've played Talisman in the past, but I don't think I'll play it again. I haven't played Runebound, and I have no desire of doing so. I guess it's neither.
Chris Page: Runebound, with two or three players.
starbug: Both! If I want to play the game all the way to the end, probably Runebound.
Loquutus: Talsiman.
fFish: Dungeon Twister? Descent: Journeys in the Dark?
mgoddard: Runebound
Ebon Wendigo: Talisman
davedanger: neither
MisterCranky: Talisman, since I have yet to play the other.
richdknows: Talisman
GI Joe: Talisman, but then I've never played Runebound, only read about it.
POvidiusNaso: Runebound, because I've never played it.
Great Dane: Talisman
javelin98: Talisman
LudesFactor: neither
CharlieWonka: Talisman
Legend Dan: Talisman!
sourwyrm: neither
bucklen_uk: Neither (got most of the 2nd edition Talisman stuff, never play it now)
skrutsch: neither
erli: Neither
leece: Well I'd rather chew off my own arm to not play Talisman again, so given a choice between the two I'd play Runebound, but I haven't played it before. Probably a mistake.
ssmooth: Neither
2amp: talisman (with house rules added)
meshuggener: Neither.
Lord_Prussian: Haven't played either
abimilech: If you're gona play D & D.. just play D & D!
Basilius: Return of the Heroes
rapier1642: Talisman
WasQ: AAAcs, I like Runebound a lot. But Return of the Heroes is a great game, maybe more than Runebound...aaargh! I said it!
melissa: neither
AWildEep: n
nerotora: I like Runebound but I love Talisman. I have all the expansions of Talisman and use them (except the City). It provides a very fun gaming experience for us. We prefer to play it when we are 3 of us. With 4 people it can take some time before you get your turn.
toulouse: never played em
Bearcat89: None of the above.
Snooze_uk: Talisman
xlorp: Magic Realm!!!
cobra: talisman
heli: Talisman
Wintergoblin: neither
kennyb: neither
garea37: Neither, Return of the Heroes!!!
snoozefest: runebound
AlorielLelyn: Neither
Windopaene: Neither
hibikir: Both bad
GuyHill: Talisman
gnomehome: Talisman
Jim_P: Neither
Chris Schreiber: neitehr
m_r_tyler: Runebound
viogression: Runebound. It's cheaper
shumyum: neither, although I WANT to like them
Blackwind: Runebound HAS to be better than Talisman.
Cardinal Fang: Talisman
rochs77: neither, but I would break down and play either if that was the only thing my opponent would try.
Mordachai: Talisman... runebound is way too unbalanced.
isolated: Runebound.
alfredhw: Dungeoneer
fellonmyhead: Neither
DangerMouse: Neither.
P.O.G.G.: Talisman
Belash: neither
Ludocrazy: Talisman
sumo: Neither
geberus: neither
ValJor: I played both only once and I would avoid them like the plague
chaddyboy_2000: Neither.
Flyspeck23: Talisman.
haraggan: Currently, Runebound - but Talisman will always have a place in my heart...
darthcliff: Neither
netfilterz: Unfortunately neither. Runebound has a more modern feel, but has even more useless downtime than Talisman.
CDRodeffer: I have (but have yet to try) Runebound, but it looks OK. I found Talisman kind of long and ho-hum.
skelebone: I've played neither, but Runebound did look interesting for a little while.
djlg: Neither!
BobDodgerBlue: Talisman, I've never played Runebound
jttm: Return of Heroes?
CheetohFingers: Neither
CortexBomb: Neither
dietevil: Runebound, but only with 3-4 players
ynnen: Talisman. Runebound was dreadful.
Shakar: Talisman.