First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #271?
sumo: What is the most overrated game?

sparkous: Witchcraft
PolarDad: Codenames!!!
BOBBYCAN: Gloompanzers.
hokam: Twilight Munchkin
Narlgoth: Zombicide around these parts.
oldhoss: Rock, paper scissors.
Woelf: Whatever is currently at the top of "The Hotness"
kellenfreeman: Bang
weed131: dominion
bcooperok: See previous two answers about Carcassonne and Settlers
Jatoha: all the new ones
pwilz: Well, I like it, but it's probably Agricola.
MamaRat: It's a three-way tie between Puerto Rico, Caylus, and Tichu.
WatchmanX2000: Puerto Rico
ZiggyZambo: Die Macher
heli: Now that we have stats on this I know: 1830
Little Dragon: Carcassonne.
TheArchAngel: Candyland
DHEK: Modern Art
bigbadsteve: i havent played it
karstenengelmann: Tigris and Euphrates
the_redstar_swl: The one YOU LIKE!
Chris Page: Bingo.
POvidiusNaso: Ticket to Ride.
Brentoon: Star Wars: Lego or whatever it is....I mean....what the hell?
GrimJester: Candyland
richdknows: chess
duLac956: San Juan
greglios: E&T. Maybe. I haven't played it.
joebelanger: Carcassonne
MaksimSmelchak: Puerto Rico. Gameplay is fine, but some folks seems to think that PR is the "Ambrosia of the Gods."
Godeke: Caylus, because I didn't get to it a BGG.CON.
John3: chess
Big Bad Lex: SOC
Nekura: Busen Memo
Helenoftroy: Arkham Horror
Moglet: Trivial Pursuit
Loquutus: Princes of Florence, the cure for insomnia
brainrob: Settlers ... too luck driven for me
Eddy Bee: Ra
javelin98: Puerto Rico
Gecko23: Power Grid. With Go a close second.
nventit: Uno(R) by Mattel, but it is my competition in all fairness to them.
GuyHill: el grande
scriptorum: St. Petersburg
Thedalek: Magic: The Gathering.
Lord_Prussian: Star Wars-The Queen's Gambit
Cavedog_pdx: Age of Steam
2amp: go
ssmooth: Wallenstein
sourwyrm: monopoly
warpozio: monopoly
matthew.marquand: Monopoly
melissa: the bad Medici - because it is so often confused with the Knizia
Rukasu: Monopoly.
Flyboy Connor: Monopoly
Mangler: Settlers of Catan - little too random.
gmcnish: Monopoly
The Unbeliever: 42
BaSL: LOTR:C
Metaphora: Cranium.
mrbeankc: Settlers of Catan
skrutsch: Monopoly.
Lord Baldrick: Monopoly
otrex: El Grande
kimapesan: War of the Ring
kennyb: power grid, lost cities
AWildEep: Monopoly, or perhaps tic tac toe
bacco: Lost cities
Toxidyne: MTG
DenverWolf: Puerto Rico
TragicHeroBC: Puerto Rico. I do love the game dearly, and it's probably in my Top 10, but I just don't think it's the best game. However, this is just a matter of opinion.
Tim Synge: War of the Ring
-Johnny-: Puerto Rico
dakarp: El Grande
Gonzaga: War of the Ring
Nightmare: Ticket to Ride
Chris Schreiber: Power Grid
fsumarc: POTSM
puffinge: Tichu
Blackwind: War of the Ring
DangerMouse: Puerto Rico
Krishna: Puerto Rico
djlg: Settlers of Catan has more ratings than any other game. Therefore its overrated.
Ludocrazy: Chess
chaddyboy_2000: Pancreitis.
geberus: TI3
disclamer: E&T
JoeSteadman: PR
Dave: Usually I would say "Puerto Rico". However, I just checked the BGG Top 10, and as stunned to see Wallenstein up there... so that's my new answer.
raolsson: Monopoly
Shakar: Puerto Rico.
Melantha: Lord of the Rings.
Pseudo Nymh: I think El Grande. I just don't understand it's appeal.
snoozefest: lost cities? M44? War of the Ring? All the wargames?
Denise: Honestly? Puerto Rico. That doesn't mean I don't like it, I love it, but it's not the be-all and end-all.
francobollus: Age of Steam
queequeg: dunno
MisterCranky: I'd like to say Settlers, because aside from its use as a gateway it holds almost no appeal for me any more. Plus, I already know that Sumo answered that way, so I might get points. On the other hand, Potterama has convinced me: It is E&T
Jim_P: Ticket to Ride
jttm: PoF
sumo: Settlers
simon craddock: Settlers
WonderCinz: Goa
Gelatinous Goo: Lost Cities
Rubric: Overrated by who? On BGG, Puerto Rico is overrated (not that it's bad or anything). In the rest of the world, Monopoly is obviously overrated.
TamiWhitsett: puerto rico
hibikir: Again? Still Puerto Rico
pernishus: Princes of Florence
Skyjack: Once Upon a Time
Hallow: ASL
janiera: Any wargame
Fawkes: Overrated on BGG vs. my personal viewpoint, it has to be War of the Ring right now. What a crappy themeless game.
shotokanguy: Puerto Rico
skelebone: Basketball.
CDRodeffer: Hammer of the Scots
Thosw: Settlers of Catan
Linnaeus: Settlers of Catan
Donkey Thong: Carcassonne
louiseh: Acquire
silverpenny: The most overrated game is the one that is ranked highest, but one that you have marked really low, for some reason or other.
Gargoyle: Puerto Rico. A rather good game, but not that brilliant.
Zambogirl: Puerto Rico
ynnen: Ra, T&E -- take your pick
Friendless: TTR
Spielfreak: Taj Mahal
Drewcooter: Settlers of Catan
CortexBomb: That I've played...probably Saint Petersburg
Flyspeck23: Settlers of Catan (while good, it ain't *that* good).
Geosphere: Puerto Rico
Dante_Cubit: Puerto Rico
Snooze_uk: Go
ValJor: War of the Ring
shumyum: Munchkin.
Debate: TTR
TD2008YDS: puerto rico
gnomehome: To each his own