First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #310?
Ryno8: Is George Lucas capable of making a good movie?

rlcoon: Not in a very long time.
Woelf: Yes, several.
BOBBYCAN: Yes.
oldhoss: Yes. He did. Obviously he is also capable of making some bad movies. But that doesn't take away from the good.
Jatoha: better than me, that's fo' sho'
whac3: obviously having done so repeatedly
kmbx13: Yes
bcooperok: Yes. And then he is capable of totally f-ing it up in rerelease.
Moose Jaw: Is the Pope Polish?
Limey Sponge: He did. Oh, did you mean make another one?
Felimid: Yes ... as long as someone else does the directing (notice how good "Empire Strikes Back" was, and see if you can say the same about Star Wars I, II or III).
Hendal: what ever, and i take it you can do better then the first start wars?
galenochfarlig: Yes...
Tushratta: He has.
Numskull: Probably, although he chooses not to.
alcazar84: He made 6 awesome ones! What kind of a question is this?
Zarion of Arabel: no
Polgara: maybe
Blott: Yes. He made Star Wars (the greatest movie of all time.)
Boot2daHead: Not lately. American Graffiti was good though. Of course, that was 1973...
WonderLlama: Yes, but he never will again.
DHEK: Yeah... didn't he already prove that many times over?
TheArchAngel: maybe in the year 2100
reverendvader: Yes.
Chris Page: Capable, yes. But that's not the smart way to bet.
duchamp: THX 1138
mpw182: Yes, many. But Episode I was a miss.
disclamer: yes. no.
purvisa: Yes, though it has been a while.
mcross: He used to make some great ones
simonjauk: Yes, back in the 70's
Dweeb: Not anymore. Any why should he bother?
Cut & Space: Duh!!!
dmomo: I hope so. Indy 4 isn't far from the making.
Beelzebub: Obviously not.
Cromaa: I think so...he's done it quite a few times already.
scriptorum: Sure.
vampywife: i doubt it
Gizensha: Yes. Or at least he used to be. Weather he still is is open for debate.
Lexi: no
Peter Palmer: LOL
verandi: return of the sith was good but not good enough to make up for his other failures.
Kazin: Well, at least he's got it in him..
Major Sholto: Yes
bigbadsteve: a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away...
brumeister: not anymore
modboy: Ys
ctalbot: Maybe thirty years ago.
Bahamut-X: Why not
mats-k: Probably not.
puffinge: he's proven that he is
jtong77: He has good ideas and creativities, but he cannot write nor direct.
Cerebus: No.
Culvan: Writing, yes. Directing, no.
Mikebegeta: yeah
TMJJS: yes
Lord_Prussian: Yes, he has anyways
pedrolisboa: Not anymore
The Unbeliever: 42
mrbeankc: Not anymore
antiussentiment: take away his budget and he'd no doubt make a riper...
shotokanguy: Yes, certainly the original Star Wars movie was "good" by almost any measure.
Randy Cox: Sure
Otterdance: Yes
TaliaIsabelle: Definitely
Musti: No.
skrutsch: Yes.
r2mites: Not since the original Star Wars
Claytonius Maximus: Heck yes he is. Like about 6 of 'em.
jmagnini: no
AWildEep: On his own, no.
kennyb: not lately
midgetsrawk: not any more
2amp: yes, star wars
heli: who knows
Malacoda: No.
Mike A: Culpable?
AlorielLelyn: THX1138
DenverWolf: YES
Ebonwoulfe: Meesa lost mucho hope in Lucas
Cavedog_pdx: Yes he most certainly is but then he keeps messing with the finished product.
[Deleted user]: Sometimes, in spite of himself
thoia: If he had the ability to remove the dollar signs from his vision, and somehow dig deep inside himself and remember what it was all about year ago when he first started out. Refule the passion of acutally creating a movie instead of the passion of buying a small south pacific island, the yes he could quite possibly make a fantastic movie. Yet we all know none of those things will ever happen again.
Wernazuma: sure, heretic! Star Wars I-III (yes, ep.4-6, kids...)!!!
BilboAtBagEnd: I think that, currently, he tries too hard.
Nightmare: Not anymore... just wait till he 'remakes' Star Wars IV, V, and VI !!!!!!!!!!!!
Grimwold: Perhaps once he was... now no longer.
Jackwraith: Not anymore
GuyHill: star wars wasnt so bad (episodes 4-6 i mean)
Gecko23: No
Blackwind: no, he was never capable
cad614: Yes, but that dosen't mean it will happen.
isolated: Not anymore.
Ravsitar: Yes, but he has to outline the general idea and let someone else write it. He MIGHT be allowed to direct it.
DangerMouse: Yes, he just hasn't done it in a while now.
m_r_tyler: I'll take that as an attack on Lucas. You, sir, are clueless.
Abundance of Flowers: Yes
fizzix: Star Wars suggests that he "was" capable at one point.
Glarbung: I've heard rumours, but cannot confirm it.
geberus: He never was, just really good at marketing
netfilterz: Yes, I like THX1138 a lot. That aside, once finished he should leave his movies alone...
wcordewiner: Yes
nm156: Yes
djlg: Yes. "Raiders of the Lost Ark"? Ok, he only co-wrote it. How about "Herbie"?
Belash: no
BobDodgerBlue: Yes
raolsson: Yes. The Empire Strikes Back
jens_hoppe: Appearently not...
Critical Mass: he is capable of making saccharine out of celluloid.
HappyProle: Not anymore.
djflippy: Not anymore.
Denise: Well, yes, he used to make good movies all the time.
Shakar: Yes.
dakarp: Well, he has been, and I actually have some hope for the new Star Wars...
Jim_P: I doubt it
hooded_paladin: Not quite.
jttm: THX1138
sumo: Yes.
Aldie: Not anymore.
hakko504: Yes. Star Wars Ep4 A New hope proves that.
UhhhClem: Even a stopped clock tells the right time twice a day.
Draugnar: No
scribidinus: As long as it doesn't involve directing real actors, maybe.
manowarplayer: Oh please.
ScottBecker: Yes
WonderCinz: Not any more.
EYE of NiGHT: Not any more.
TamiWhitsett: yep
melissa: He was. The first 3 movies (chronologically not in the story sequence) were wonderful. These days? *shudder*
Joe Cool: no
tragicpoet: We'll find out in a year or two
LudesFactor: certainly, he's done several ...
Sky Knight X: Yes, I have seen some.
PghArch: Was? Yes! Is? Not so sure.
berserkley: He did: American Graffiti; so I'd say yes
janiera: Yes
Fawkes: Capable? You're kidding right? He's already made more than a lot of other directors!
fnord23: theoretically
Flyspeck23: Define "good".
Hallow: every one of his movies are good ;-0
CDRodeffer: Was or Is?
echoota: "First you have it, then you don't"
Xlyce: Yes, THX-1138
MisterCranky: Historically, no.
shumyum: He was...
gashlycrumb: Not recently.
Reloaded: Yes, don't be hating... :)
ejmowrer: Yes, but he should direct trailers for a living. Those have all been good.
HBGlover: Sure. Just not writing or directing one. He belongs in the producer's chair.
Linnaeus: Probably not anymore
snoozefest: no
bbenston: He's capable of making *decent* movies, like THX or American Graffiti. Good movies? Doubt it.
nix342: not any more
okiedokie: Radioland Murders (but w/o the nudity)
louiseh: Yes
jdroscha: not anymore
Ryno8: Not since I turned 15
dietevil: Yes, if he hires someone else to do the screenplay.
hibikir: No
Jon_1066: Not any more
bard: Producing and coming up with the story -- Yes. Directing and writing it -- No. (Although I still have hope... please please please...)
rochs77: Dear God no
Zambogirl: yes
Debate: So I'm told
Spielfreak: yes
ValJor: Yes, he has done it many times
CortexBomb: Now or in the past?
ynnen: Well, he did make THX and American Graffiti...
skelebone: At one time he was.. but has the magic left him?
Friendless: Not since I've grown up.
WasQ: I hope yes
chaddyboy_2000: Probably
mdp4828: no
gnomehome: Only time will tell
Geosphere: Yes. But not the way everyone expects him to.