First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #3267?
[Deleted user]: [deleted question]

Chris Page: Wasn't there a James Ernest game, "Landyland" published years ago?
nvarela: I'd rather hammer my finger...
MisterCranky: I think Culdcept Saga covers the basics of that idea on the 360 pretty well, although certainly not precisely.
vandemonium: Sounds great, copyrighted and patented. You owe me 150$ for infringing on my idea :p
42ndSSD: A game which combines Monopoly deed cards, Magic the Gathering cards, and Satanic meeples would be a real winner.
waza: No and No
Skullsplitter: definitely NOT!
xlorp: Let's counterspell that idea right now
TMuscle: PRetty cool and creative.
KrisVerbeeck: dull²
DHEK: I think it needs a whole lot of refinement to make it work. And I'm not sure if it'll even be any good.
aleo09: ok
GreenK: probably wouldn't play it. MtG has a stigma
xandryyte: Eh... No thanks...
eddyspaghetti: Too tiny to see easily.
scriptorum: I think you've got a little work left before Magic: The Settling takes off.
POvidiusNaso: Design it.
Beelzebub: No thanks
arkibet: play test it and see
mrspank: Sounds decent. Now you need to flesh out the rules and find a publisher.
Avatar_69: Design it and I'll give it a try.
miyazakigrognard: That game was called "Magic Realm".
Shotmagnet: zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Big Bad Lex: Shite
dwarf: Oh no! Collectable Settlers!
bigbadsteve: it could work
jellospike: snore...
brainrob: The bastard son of two overrated abominations should be drowned at birth.
Randy Cox: wbc
Fawkes: You don't ruin a brilliant game like Magic by combining it with a weak game like Settlers.
SenorOcho: Now that's just silly.
Tennantgamer: actually sounds pretty good--I may sit down and hammer out some rules tonight
sumo: I think I might pass.
RicBret: Isn't that set to ship in October? OOOPS!
fellonmyhead: Send me your prototype and I'll tell you what I think.
Dr. No: I think its called Magic Realm
GrandpaDave: Uh...no
Karlsen: Too slow
The Unbeliever: 42
sourwyrm: hmm
Jittle: Hasn't it already been made? Could be fun.
Bergbau: Why not put in some other stuff?
Lord_Prussian: I think not
StormKnight: Oooooh...starts thinking up rules...
djlg: Its very derivative.
snoozefest: have to try it. I do like both games, although it seems like an odd combo
2amp: don't play either so my opinion is invalid
skrutsch: Sounds intriguing.
CDRodeffer: Right. Doesn't sound like it would be all that great.
Bearcat89: Non.
chaddyboy_2000: I'm thinking that I want some ham and cheese omelette.
darthcliff: Sounds cool! Post the rules.
Spielfreak: The first step of the program is to lock up the cards. Please, you'll never recover from your M:tG addiction unless you stick to the 12-step program.
jttm: Magic has no dice. Settlers, lots of dice.
puffinge: yea, I think Magic is elegant too. I like the idea if we can eliminate that Settlers roll.
heli: don't like the CCG aspect
CortexBomb: One of the more elegant games to ever come down the pike combined with one of the most convoluted?
skelebone: Sure, get right on that.
Dave: I think you should check out FFG's Vortex/Maelstrom.