First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #3660?
francobollus: Shadows over Camelot or Lord of the Rings?

ocdspectrum: Never played the latter. Get both.
thegeekess: Shadows over Camelot
Dutys_Fist: Game v. Franchise with many games. Moar Games = Moar Win. LoTR wins.
hellium: Lord of Camelot is better than a Shadow over you Ring
Gorgoneion: Shadows
Spirit of 70: Lord of the Rings.
Chris Busse: LOTR
Woelf: Battlestar Galactica
daveroswell: Shadows
pwilz: I've never played LOTR, but I really really like Shadows.
hob69: dunno, really
cgund: ni
timstellmach: LotR generally. LotR delivers more of a narrative, which I like in co-ops.
royaldoy: Shadows over Camelot. I found Lord of the Rings blahh.
milhouse46: Lord of the Rings
waza: Shadows
ritterman: Shadows over Camelot.
ithicks: Shadows over Camelot
compman: Shadows Over Camelot
WalkerRedEye: quiet like shadows and i only played lord of teh riings once and only the basic rules i much preferred shadows
DHEK: I've not tried any LOTR boardgame, so I'll go with Shadows over Camelot since that's not bad.
Cmot Dribbler: Neither
Ebon Wendigo: Shadows Over Camelot
Zot!: Shadows over Camelot
hacksword: Nope.
aleo09: haven't played either, yet.
LordT: Haven't played SoC yet, so LotR
jeffwolfe: Either one.
steef: Shadows
PsyJam: I haven't played SoC, but LotR is good every now and then.
pitferret: Shadows.
DHolte: Lord of the Rings
Dorque: Nope.
Firepigeon: LotR
joebelanger: Both?
Helenoftroy: LotR
rawdawg: no
Chris Page: Shadows over Camelot, thanks to the traitor.
scriptorum: Dunno yet. Haven't played SoverC yet.
Platinum Dragon: LotR.
fFish: Haven't played SoC yet
twixter: I don't even know what SoC was- a book? a movie? a rock group? I loved LotR as books and as movies.
Odat: Shadows over Camelot, as long as I'm playing with people who don't just put seige engines out for the first 10 consecutive turns.
puffinge: no thanks
MochaKimono: LoTR.
javelin98: LOTR
tragicpoet: Shadows
djlg: Shadows is purtier.
ping9x: Shadows over Camelot (newer)
Mike A: I'd like to try either.
GrandpaDave: SOC
kytmuisco: Shadows over Camelot, without a doubt. In Lord of the Rings, I usually just take control of the fellowship anyway and make most of the decisions because no one I play with can make decisions in co-operative games.
ekted: LotR
matthew.marquand: LotR
Bandit Ripshawd: Oooh... Haven't played SoC, but I do love LotR.
snoozefest: SoC, although I haven't played it yet - it's coming MONDAY!
Ludocrazy: Haven't gotten to try Camelot yet
davidme: Shadows
sourwyrm: haven't played em
skrutsch: to the death?
Great Dane: SoC
Lord_Prussian: I don't really care for coop games. I haven't tried Shadows yet. I don't like LotR. I sort of like Betrayal on the Hill.
CDRodeffer: I haven't played Shadows over Camelot yet, but I wasn't really all that impressed with Lord of the Rings. The base game was fine, but Sauron seemed to be a broken expansion.
chaddyboy_2000: I haven't played both yet.
Claytonius Maximus: SoC
jttm: SC
Spielfreak: Camelot, Camelot, Camelot ... it's only a model...
skelebone: I've played neither, so I don't have an opinion on them.