First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #397?
ejmowrer: Dune or Ender's Game?

ocdspectrum: Twilight Imperium IV.
BOBBYCAN: I never could get in to Ender's Game so I never saw the movie. Dune, of course, is just weird, so yeah.
Phil Fleischmann: I have to add my vote to Ender's Game, but I liked Dune, too. So the score so far is: Dune 56, Ender's Game 38, essentially tied 17, don't know 13, non-responsive 8.
oldhoss: Started reading both, never finished either. Not for me, I guess.
Felimid: Dune.
bcooperok: gah. really? Both are so lame.
qwints: Ender's Game
dove: Dune
jessitron: Dune. I love Ender's Game but Dune is larger in scope.
aleo09: haven't played either
capt yid: Both good, but Ender's Game definitely better,
rgatti: Ender's Game
Randy Cox: Neither.
2amp: never played either
Frubgarde: Dune. Well the first three books anyway. That series seriously disappeared up its own arse by Chapter House Dune, and don't get me started about Brian Herbert's "contribution" to the oeuvre.
danafarr: Ender's Game! Definitely Ender's Game!!!!!
krainer: Ender's Game.
Actherion: I can't answer this question fairly, as I've only read Ender's Game.
dogzard: Ender's Game, of course!
radynski: Ender's Game easily.
ZeroZilla: Strictly by first novels, Ender's Game. Dune's universe was better fleshed out, but Ender's pyschological drama is much more interesting to me. As a series, Dune probably wins out, consequently.
bigbadsteve: ??
jtrleone: I heard good things about Dune so I'll go with that.
Mike McCall: I want both!
frieque: Dune
DHEK: Played neither before.
mpw182: dune
Beelzebub: Ender's Game
mintylish: Dune
scriptorum: I never read Dune. The movie never appealed to me. I should probably pick up the book.
Avatar_69: Dune by a mile (although Ender's Game is excellent)
MaksimSmelchak: Emphatically "Ender's Game." No contest between those two authors. Herbert is an ant unto Card.
ct_cruiser: hm, heard good things about both
ststrat: Dune
Chris Page: Speaker for the Dead.
Karlsen: Ender's Game
confuse_a_cat: Ender's Game
Famous Mortimer: Neither.
POvidiusNaso: Dune.
davebo: Ender's Game. NO question.
msaari: Both, though Dune is a bigger thing (9 books on my shelf, after all)
GI Joe: No idea
Null Signature: Dune
ssmooth: Do you mean, which is the better book?
Lord_Prussian: Ender's Game
sourwyrm: ender's game
sbszine: Dune. The twist ending of Ender's Game only works once.
Gecko23: Ender's Game
Nomadik: neither
skrutsch: to the death?
kennyb: liked them both
shotokanguy: Ender's Game.
einbebop: ender's game
HappyProle: Haven't read Ender's Game, but Dune is pretty damn good.
Blindsun: Dune
Claytonius Maximus: Ender's Game (but not the dude who keeps asking Canadian questions)
Quest22: Dune
Windopaene: Dune
steadym: Ender's Game.
ginn5j: Dune
-Johnny-: Dune, Ender's Game was nothing special
heli: Dune
GuyHill: Enders Game
Toxidyne: Ender's game because the individual matters more.
m_r_tyler: Dune. EndersGame asks too many questions.
toulouse: bleah.
AlorielLelyn: Dune. Orson Scott Card irritates me.
Ryno8: Ender's Game
redhuntingcap: Dune
Salt-Man Z: Ender's Game.
gnomehome: Dune
Cal Mac: Dune, but not by a long way.
Johan: Haven't read Dune, but it is bound to be better than Ender's Game.
shippert: Dune. That cyberpunk crap creeps me out.
mrbeankc: Enders Game
squonk: Dune.
Grod: Dune
Blackwind: Dune
threlicus: Ender's Game is the better read. Dune is deeper.
CortexBomb: Haven't played for either, but given the choice of which to hit first I would choose Dune
Mordachai: Both books are good - written for different ages though.
jttm: Dune
puffinge: Ender's Game
djflippy: Dune
onky: None.
chaddyboy_2000: Ack.
dakarp: Probably Dune, but it's been a while since I've read Ender's Game.
Sky Knight X: Ender's Game
sdownin: Ender's Game
geberus: ender's game
UhhhClem: Dune.
netfilterz: Dune.
rickkeuler: Ender's Game (but I haven't read Dune - only saw the movie.)
Silbach: Dune.
Reloaded: Ender's Game
louiseh: Ender's Game.
nienie: dune
BobDodgerBlue: Dune
Shakar: Dune.
Eric Haas: Yes
Scott Firestone IV: Dune.
yossarians: Ender's
Pseudo Nymh: Ender's Game.
snoozefest: ender's game
manowarplayer: Dune
Friendless: Dune
djlg: Dune
queequeg: Dune
kostas: Dune
silverpenny: Yep.
hooded_paladin: Dune. Hated Ender's Game.
Critical Mass: yes please
kimbo: Nope. Won't do it. I won't choose one over the other. Both are great!
LudesFactor: Dune
pernishus: Dune, baby
WonderCinz: Ender's Game, definitely.
TamiWhitsett: ender's game
WasQ: Dune
Aldie: Dune is better, but Ender is more fun.
Debate: Ender's, definitely
MisterCranky: Well, on the one hand you have a guy writing a nice book, but he only has two first names. Then this other guy, with two names and a noun writes some other book, which is pretty interesting in its own right. Screw it, Dune.
PghArch: Dune
hibikir: Dune is better written, but I think Ender's game is deeper.
sumo: Dune
Jim_P: Dune
Zambo: Dune
Zambogirl: neither
CDRodeffer: I have to confess that I haven't read either.
viogression: Ender's Game
dietevil: Dune (but I like EG too)
shumyum: Dune in a sandslide
HBGlover: Oof, what a question! Dune. It's more adult. However, I've never read the rest of the Dune series, and I enjoyed the rest of the Ender's series alot.
ejmowrer: Can't decide.
EndersGame: Ender's Game
skelebone: I've only read one, and I like that one.