First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #413?
manowarplayer: Most over-rated game you have played? (or Why do people like this so much?)

Jrtolf: Terra Mystica or Xia? What to choose?! WHAT TO CHOOSE??!!
silvermandus: rdr2
PhotoJim: Dead of Winter.
oldhoss: Le Havre or Puerto Rico. Although I do like saying "Le Havre."
Hendal: puerto rico = boring
richcharters: Survive! It's a game made for kids, but has a mean spirit to it. Come here son, let me sink your boat and kill your guys!!
Woelf: Le Havre - I can see why a lot of people really like it, but to me it felt like a bloated, needlessly over-complicated remake of Agricola.
Liberto: Is it Ok to say Chess.
AssaultMarine: Agricola
Vapor11: Brink
Danoru: Settlers of Catan or the Halo series, depending on what type of game you're talking about.
TiwazTyrsfist: Reiner Knizia's Lord of the Rings game. I hated that.
bcooperok: Monopoly. God that thing is awful.
Jatoha: I usually get rid of ones I don't care for
ts061282: Warhammer
Phil Fleischmann: Ticket to Ride
Spirit of 70: Age of Steam. To me, it is an exercise in tedium.
daveroswell: The GRIC
syphon: Race for the Galaxy.
Diamat: Puerto Rico. Who'd have known that a whole new world of dull waited for me.
geneandcourtney: knuckles
vampywife: now you're just trying to open a can of worms, aren't you? let's see, for the moment, i'll go with Arkham Horror, but I've only played it once, so it's due a second chance.
burbidge: Dungeons & Dragon. It's okay but come on.
DHEK: Modern Art.
Der Ubermolch: Modern Art. Total snooze-fest.
applejuicefool: Checkers
DGSI: American Idol the video game....because people love american idol
sandysidamo: Lost Cities
Brentoon: why are there so many questions about things that r overrated
Leo-T: Caylus
Mr_Six: Carcassonne
jeffwolfe: PR
duchamp: Ingenious
Frankenfletch: Magic the Gathering
Capitaine Grappin: Settlers of Catan
greglios: I don't think I've played any games I'd consider over-rated.
bigbadsteve: whack-a-mole
mooka: Princes of Florence
Cromaa: Settles of Catan
brainrob: Settlers
Dorque: Puerto Reeko.
mlanza: Diplomacy
WatchmanX2000: Puerto Rico
Big Bad Lex: Shadows Over Camelot
Chris Page: Blackjack.
Torquato: Puerto Rico. A good game, of course. But not the best game ever.
Loquutus: Princes of Florence, Goa, Alhambra, Carcasonne. i can't figure it out but they all suck.
Helenoftroy: Lost Cities. It seems that is the only game men can get their SO to play. I still hate the game and upset that everyone suggested it to my husband to play with his GAMER wife.
POvidiusNaso: Ticket to Ride. I find it pretty mediocre.
noon: Princes of Florence
gamesbook: Runebound
jellospike: Settlers, I guess.
javelin98: Most card games -- poker, blackjack, bridge, etc.
GrandpaDave: Magic The Gathering
Culvan: Bang.
mrbeankc: Settlers of Catan
verandi: La Citta
Gecko23: Power Grid. I want my $30 back!
msbtch2u: torres.
BaSL: LOTR:C³
Windopaene: Power Grid...a fine game, but one I don't enjoy all that much
Lord_Prussian: Settlers
SwedeLad: Tiddlywinks
rawk: myst
erli: Rainbow Fish...the shiny scales win me over every time
heli: Lord of the Rings and Lord of the Rings Risk
jens_hoppe: Twilight Imperium
DenverWolf: Puerto Rico
AlorielLelyn: Magic: the gathering
dakarp: Robo Rally
jimchris: Lord of the Rings. Even though I can understand the reasons some people state for it... can't figure out what those reasons have to do with a good game though...
gnomehome: Check my ratings versus the average rating
fizzix: Maharaja
Cal Mac: Pass the Pigs
thoia: St. Petersburg
Fawkes: Overrated on BGG vs. my personal viewpoint, it has to be War of the Ring right now. What a crappy themeless game.
netfilterz: Can't say really...
Wernazuma: Maharaja
Johan: War of the ring... Fell for the hype and now have a big box full of plastic
CortexBomb: Maharaja? Not bad in an absolute sense, but vastly overrated...St. Pete also falls into this
StormKnight: War of the Ring
Donkey Thong: Carcassonne
geberus: TI3
Blackwind: dont know
rochs77: Carcassonne
alfredhw: 1830
ejmowrer: I'm sorry, but Puerto Rico. It's a good game, but VERY overrated. Wouldn't even be in my top 10.
DangerMouse: Puerto Rico and I'm not sure why people like it so much.
haraggan: I feel that way about almost all the highly-rated games; I'm a grinch
Ludocrazy: E&T
chaddyboy_2000: Samurai.
Ryno8: Any CCG... they start out fun, but it boggles my mind how people can play them for years.
fosterjake: Puerto Rico!!!!
djlg: Settlers of Catan
louiseh: Acquire
manowarplayer: Illuminati
Shakar: Puerto Rico.
sdownin: Ra. I hate that game with a passion.
Aldie: Halo 2
Linnaeus: Carcassonne
snoozefest: lost cities
Pseudo Nymh: El Grande. I definitely didn't see the appeal of this one, and traded it away.
Melantha: Titan.
jttm: PoF
Jim_P: Ticket to Ride
Gelatinous Goo: Carcassonne
LudesFactor: A Game of Thrones ... i've not played with the expansion for 6, but with 5, any conflict situation seemed to immediately throw the game out of balance.
Draugnar: Risk
HBGlover: Probably Power Grid. It's ok, but top-ten?
The Maverick: Settlers
statonv: El Grande
melissa: Basari
Flyspeck23: Settlers of Catan. While it's certainly good, it ain't *that* good (in my opinion).
UhhhClem: Settlers, definitely.
Thosw: Settlers of Catan
Debate: TTR
hibikir: PR.
Lardarse: Cafe International
Friendless: TTR
ValJor: British Rails
ScottBecker: yinsh
skelebone: Pirate's Cove
nix342: Goa
Zambogirl: Puerto Rico
dietevil: Formula De
CDRodeffer: Puerto Rico is way over-rated.
ynnen: Ra/T&E... for the fifth time