First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #4206?
ja_n: Which one is better? Shadows Over Camelot or Knizia's Lord of the Rings?

pwilz: I like Shadows Over Camelot, but I've never played LOTR. I like pure co-ops, but many of the people I game with regularly don't care for the hidden traitor mechanic.
Goldron: Shadows over Camelot - we love Traitors
tomojaco: gralem tylko w pierwsza, wiec nieeee wieeeem
Jbrady: Shadows over Camelot
Woelf: I've only played LotR once and was lukewarm about it, and I haven't played SoC at all. To answer your question, BSG.
weed131: Shadows
PzVIE: SoC
vandemonium: No contest, Shadows Over Camelot. PS, I am **NOT** the traitor. Trust me.
Randy Cox: Neither is worthy of playing, I think.
Heliconia: Lord of the rings is much, much better
Geosmores: Have not played either
jbuergel: Lord of the Rings
Ice X: 42
DKahnt: Lord of the Rings
everlong205: Shadows over camelot
DHEK: I've not tried Knizia's LOTR, but Shadows Over Camelot isn't too bad.
WatchmanX2000: Huh?
rydiafan: Lord of the Rings.
aleo09: never played either
JasonMatthews: Only the traitor would ask that question!
POvidiusNaso: Ultimately, I like Lord of the Rings better, but Shadows is more newbie-accessible.
vetinari7878: Haven't played LotR.
janiera: Shadows over Camelot
Ebon Wendigo: Shadows over Camelot
jasta6: don't know these games.......................
ScottBecker: Lord of the Rings
Chris Page: Shadows Over Camelot
Winter Wolf: Shadows Over Camelot.
brainrob: SOC
djlg: LotR
Fawkes: Lord of the Rings, quite easily.
puffinge: pins to my eyes, please
locusshifter: Shadows
Cavedog_pdx: Republic of Rome kicks so much ass over these
Loquutus: SoC
meshuggener: Hmm...
flieger: yes
javelin98: Camelot
sbszine: I haven't played either, but LotR is a proven winner while SoC is mostly hype at this point.
ssmooth: I'm not totally grabbed by either one.
Dave: SoC has more downtime, but LotR has more obvious decisions and seems more dry. Tough call.
mrbeankc: I'd have to say Shadows simply because I haven't played the other.
skrutsch: I haven't played Shadow's Over Camelot.
jttm: I want to play SC, but its not arrived.
skelebone: I don't know since I've not played either.
chaddyboy_2000: LotR seemed more fun.
Lord_Prussian: I don't like cooperative games usually and haven't tr
Spielfreak: SoC, as it's non-linear
CDRodeffer: I'm guessing that it almost has to be Shadows Over Camelot.