First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #43?
Karlsen: Which version of Carcassonne Farmer scoring do you use?

Woelf: 3 points for each completed city touching a field. It's more intuitive and more consistent with the other scoring methods than giving 4 points for having the most farmers touching each city. Also, ALL completed cities double in value; no exception is made for 2-tile cities.
DoctorBradford: There are more than one?
oldhoss: See my previous answer.
MartinWin: The one the other players know. In the rare case that I bring the game on the table and no one knows it I will choose the first one (for each city the player with the most neighbouring farmers gets 4 points).
Herodian: I pick a number divisible by three that seems reasonable. If nobody objects, that's how many points I get.
beerbear: OG BABY!
resin: The version where I give the game away to a friend so that I never see it again.
bcooperok: The right one.
jmsmith2434: The no-scoring version
DLongo: I use version 4.1(b) with subsection (d) added in...from the German big box version....
pooterbug: The original probably since I have an older edition
daveroswell: I don't.
erak: 3rd just because it saves so much time in scoring. I still score 2-tile "[American] football" cities 2 points though.
scriptorum: The one in my rulebook. (1st ed?)
Great Dane: 3rd edition - which is the official tournament version
Goldyn Gryphon: Neither
uiek: German one from the second edition.
aceraxon: The newer one, always stay updated.
DHEK: I've not played any the regular Carcassonne, so I'm not famliar with "farmer scoring".
Tsaar: Per field majority, counting every connected city.
ColtsFan76: After tryng to keep up with 1st edition, we moved to 3rd Edition.
aleo09: the least annoying
Capitaine Grappin: standart
GrimJester: Version 4
mcross: The RGG version
pablito76: The first one!!!!
TaliaIsabelle: Original!
bigbadsteve: i prefer the haldeman method
Shade006: None. I don't particularly like Carcassonne.
vampywife: i've never played it
FrozenHoHos: The Rio Grande rules
Chris Page: Original version, except cities are worth 3 points each rather than 4. (The 2-size cities are still only worth 2 points.)
marshalljansen: The one where you shove the little *&$%^@& up the winner's @$$ for picking a Carcassonne game.
midnightfaerie: don't remember, only played it once...
BeeCeeJay: I don't play the game often enough to know the difference off the top of my head.
RyanMC: the real one
Arcadian Del Sol: i dont own it. there's not enough combat.
the_spy: 3 points per city, a city is scored only once per player.
Fawkes: I only know the one from the RGG box.
jimv: N/A
_Kael_: Neither
Famous Mortimer: I didn't know there was more than one... the one in the rules that I have.
jellospike: I don't play that
ssmooth: The original
Bearcat89: None. Never played.
skrutsch: the original
Randy Cox: Original. Any change would mean that the earlier versions were just beta tests.
puffinge: original
jvvw: Usually the opposite from the everyone else until I remember to ask half-way through!
Topdecker: 1st edition.
Rukasu: None. I play Hunters and Gatherers so I don't have to worry about the stinkin' farmers.
The Unbeliever: 42
Gecko23: Same as BSW
stephensj23: the correct one
arkibet: New when you have a pig.
sbszine: German 3rd Ed.: 3 points per adjacent, complete city.
Lord_Prussian: The real rules
ptper: original rules version
Drewcooter: 3pt's to the player who has the most farmers farming around/supplying the city.
rkalajian: The official versin
heli: whatever the rules in the box say
2amp: don't play
kennyb: the right one...
rivo: The original: 4 points per city, counting per meadow.
Cavedog_pdx: 69
Tim Synge: Third.
UhhhClem: The one with the tigers, elephants, deer, and aurochs.
AlorielLelyn: 3 pts per closed city.
-Johnny-: 3rd
davedanger: "the-never-play-carcasse-ony-game"
Belash: 4 points
StormKnight: The one in which we don't use farmers because we play Hunters and Gatherers
Dave: If forced to play Carc, I prefer the original scoring rules.
CortexBomb: None of them, not a big Carc fan
Mordachai: Each field scores 3 (4 with pig) points per finished adjacent city.
Blackwind: I didnt know there was more than one.
isolated: The one that makes me win.
geberus: none
darthcliff: The one where I win
chaddyboy_2000: Whichever one was in the rules of the edition I bought.
fosterjake: Original 4 point rules.
BobDodgerBlue: None
Vince Londini: Original, wasn't aware of the issue until I found the Geek
raolsson: The single count.
Gelatinous Goo: the one that involves keeping the game in the box and playing something else
Ludocrazy: The current German rules
jens_hoppe: Five! Three, sir!
Gonzaga: I guess the standard version ...
HappyProle: 3 pts per farm. Score cities per farm, not farms per city.
queequeg: old school
Jim_P: 2nd
Critical Mass: neither
kimbo: The one written in the rules. (Rio Grande edition.)
MisterCranky: I only score with the lady farmers.
seppo21: All of them. Then I take the square root of the geometric mean. Plug this into log base pi function and take the inverse cosine. Then my wife rolls her eyes and throws a meeple at me.
ScottBecker: the one I remember at the time
CDRodeffer: Majority farmer scores 3 points per adjacent completed city.
dietevil: Most farmers per city, not per field
Sky Knight X: The real one
hibikir: German 2nd ed: scoring per farm, not per city
Thosw: 3rd edition - scoring per city, not per farm.
EvilTimmy: Extra crispy.
klarkinhistrep: Each city awards 4 to the player with the most farmers supplying it.
Linnaeus: None if I can help it.
snoozefest: original
Gregarius: 4 points per castle. I think it's too much, but it's the number in the rules I have.
Zambogirl: there's more than one?
Jatoha: 3 points a city
Claytonius Maximus: The one where I gave Carc away to my friend.
BaSL: more Carcassonne... aaaaaaargh!
nix342: A field scores 2pts per adjacent complete city
skelebone: Count the farmers that supply each completed city, person with the most gets 4 points.
Geosphere: H+G is better.
mnvalente: Only play -Hunters and Gatherers
gnomehome: I h8 carc.
sumo: Don't play Carc
Jon_1066: The normal one, there are others?
Friendless: original
Debate: I wasn't aware there was more than one way.
mvonahnen: The one with the bazooka wins.
ynnen: I try to avoid Carcassonne as often as possible.
Mike A: Third edition (3 points per city bordering each farm and 4 points for 2 tile cities)
melissa: The same one as you :) 4 points per city in/adjoining the meadow.
manowarplayer: Score each FIELD. Count up each players farmers in each field. The most scores 4 points per city. I don't think it's the way it was done in any version, but we like it!
janiera: 4 points per city
Shakar: The one suplied with the rules.
ensor: Rio Grande
darquil: Each city scores 4 points for the player with the most meeples supplying it.
tiredmind: i don't.
ping9x: None - I try not to play. If I do, it's the one that is in the rulebook so I don't have to worry about arguments.
ValJor: The one that the other guys agree upon, I really don't care much.
jttm: A variant I created to simplify things. (okay, I misread the rules)
Aldie: the hard way