First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #5090?
erli: From what you've seen so far, do you like the new Reef Encounter art or the old?

Woelf: Have not played either version.
Neal Smith: Nit seen them. Next!
perrygf: I prefer real reefs.
Caerid: Considering I have not seen either I can't make any kind of inteligent decision on that, so: I like cookies.
Randy Cox: I never saw either the old or the new.
puffinge: I still haven't seen the new, and it's October of 08. But I haven't been trying.
Oeternalis: Haven't seen the old one, so I'll say the new one.
Cringing Dragon: What I've seen so far would be very little, so I can't really comment.
Narlgoth: Er.. Haven't seen it :- .
Suzan: I like both
El Hidalgo: New
KrisVerbeeck: old
POvidiusNaso: New.
michely: Both seems ok, but I think I prefer the old one for the game part and the new one for the box.
jcarvin: Either way is fine by me.
DHEK: I've not seen either.
elirlandes: I have not seen it so far.
aleo09: haven't compared
Geosphere: I don't bother with euros
Gnarlythotep: Both are decent, but I prefer the old.
hacksword: New.
Brentoon: i like you FACE!
iamalias: Neither. They don't compare to the real thing.
UhhhClem: The new is perfectly fine.
Dorque: Nope.
Cromaa: Haven't seen either
vampywife: n/a
nexttothemoon: New...especially since it's 1/4 the price.
mats-k: New
djlg: Old
jasta6: Not seen either.............................................................
Platinum Dragon: Having seen nothing so far, my answer is: squiggly-squooch.
Jim_P: New
brainrob: Old
melissa: yes
LemonyFresh: Old's always better than new, except when it isn't
Tim Synge: The old what?
ssmooth: I didn't realize there was any new Reef Encounter art. I didn't find the old especially tantalizing.
mrbeankc: I haven't played either
dakarp: based just on the box art and the reference cards, I definitely prefer the old art.
heli: haven't seen the new, but old was fine
chaddyboy_2000: I like the new.
jttm: Dunno. Old?
sumo: Old
Lord_Prussian: both
Spielfreak: old
CDRodeffer: I like the box art better in the Z-Man edition, but I haven't seen anything else.
skelebone: I think they both look great.
CortexBomb: I prefer the older art, I liked the more whimsical style of Breese