First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #5388?
noon: If the gal who always draws the cards she needs played Memoir '44 against the guy who always rolls hits when he needs them, who would win?

Woelf: Cards, assuming she still gets a normal randomized distribution of die roll odds.
TallonAM: I think the powers allowed by the cards will overpower luck rolls
Hendal: the guy who sells them Memoir 44'
corross: The gal. The cards still matter more.
Volfield: The girl. If you ain't got the cards, you can't roll the dice.
jruddy: In war, no one really wins...
potza4: Guy with the hits.
Twinge: I'll tell you who wouldn't win: the starving children in Arica.
1000rpm: I guess I need to think about this longer than I can be bothered to. And does he only roll hits when he "needs" them? Not 'always'? If so I'd go with the gal.
Chrisgmay: The guy who always the hits!
Patticus: the hits guy hands down
DHEK: The guy. Good rolls are better than good cards.
slowcorner: We ALL would win, wouldn't we?
2amp: i don't know the game. do cards modify dice rolls? then i'll take the cards over the dice any day
biggdork: The guy. It's tough to win a battle of maneuvre's when your army is a smoldering, bullet riddled pile of corpses across the battlefield.
mpw182: me
Chris Page: The cat that can't resist knocking over game pieces.
GornTC: The guy. One can only play 1 card per turn, but can roll many times across the board.
MaksimSmelchak: It would be a draw... right? LOL :)
Dorque: Cards.
Bubbi: The Girl
scriptorum: The guy who rolls hits.
XenoMaster: The people who sold you the game (don't like it much myself)
Laudwic: the girl if the guy is smart
jasta6: the Gal..........................................................................
brainrob: Always the gal
drummermark: The Girl, she would get all the counter cards.
mrspank: The guy.
Kazin: Roller.
bigbadsteve: does he benefit in any way by her winning? if so, she does
djlg: Assuming random distributions otherwise, "always hits" would win.
LemonyFresh: Interesting. I suppose the guy.
Fawkes: No one, since they're playing Memoir '44.
skrutsch: him
RonStock: The guy... girls will never be any good at any type of game.
casrina: the guy
fellonmyhead: The guy - don't you know anything about logic?
CDRodeffer: The best roller.
chaddyboy_2000: I just answered this.
jttm: The guy.
Lord_Prussian: Um, as I said before, the one with the rolls will win.
heli: If you drop a cat with face up buttered toast strapped to its back, how does it land?
skelebone: Card drawer -- the guy who can roll well would get stuck with a handful of cards that let him move in the wrong section.