First |
Prev ||
Next |
Last
¿Question #5645?
puffinge: Would you prefer a movie to be thoroughly engrossing throughout but have a very disappointing ending or be somewhat boring throughout and have a stunning, memorable conclusion? Can you give examples of each of this type of movie?
Woelf: Memorable endings tend to be the most memorable part after the fact.
locusshifter: Sausage.
pwilz: I'd say 'Tango & Cash' is a good example of the first. For the second, I would use 'Lost in Translation.'
Phil Fleischmann: An example of the first would be "No Country for Old Men". I'm not sure what you mean by the second. Whatever happens at the end isn't going to be "stunning" or "memorable" if I don't really care about the characters or the story, no matter how spectacular they try to make it.
Geosmores: I would like something in between
sujihime: The somewhat boring movie. And no, I can not give an example.
Impr3ssion: Second one. uhhhh... Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Thelma and Louise.
SilverDrake: First "crank", second one "Starship Troopers 2". Definitly the last one.
DHEK: I think the first is the lesser of two evils. At least I would have enjoyed the ride, rather than be bored so much for most of the movie and then not really care that much to enjoy the great ending as much. As for examples... nah... I don't wanna think too hard to answer this question, so I'll pass.
Leo-T: I don't care for either, but I guess I'd rather see the 2nd. First type: Matrix series - we saw a much cooler ending coming, then were disappointed. 2nd type: Moby Dick - loooong and boring, then good action & ending.
UhhhClem: I can't think of a dull movie with a memorable conclusion. But I'd prefer it over the likes of HERO.
KentuckyKid: Good throughout, disappointing end would be my choice (Vanilla Sky). I can't think of examples of the other type.
vampywife: can't we have a middle ground? a decent movie throughout with a great ending? as for the other kinds, the disappointing ending has happened a lot lately, starting with Cast Away and moving on along. as for the boring to stunning conclusion, i'm not sure.
kspieler: I would prefer the movie that is engrossing throughout except the end, and no I cannot give you any examples.
djlg: No I wouldn't prefer either of those. No.
mlanza: I prefer the latter. Respective examples: Planet of The Apes remake, The Sixth Sense
ssmooth: I wouldn't be very favorably impressed by either. An example of a movie I thought was good until I got to the really dumb ending would be A Few Good Men. I can't think of an example of the other type.
Big Bad Lex: zzzzzzzzzzzzz
Kazin: Stunning memorable conclusion. No examples.
Jim_P: beter ending... e.g.-Hulk, better middle... The Forgotten
brainrob: Neither, thanks
Loquutus: Woa, deja vu.
jttm: Why can't I have both? Why not a movie thats boring throughout and have a disappointing ending? Is that really too much to ask?
skelebone: I don't care for movies that much.
scriptorum: Both have their strong points. No, I'm too lazy to think.
puffinge: Randy, this is an activity in decline. If you recall, last time I only gave each movie a rating and a one-line review. I try to see 30 movies before releasing the reviews, but I'm seeing movies at a much slower pace these days. I've seen about 22 movies since the last Take. So either I lower that 30-number or I have to see 8 more movies.
Randy Cox: Bill, when are more of your reveiws coming out?
Dave: The latter. While not exactly "stunning", I was moved by the ending of Big Fish so much it cast the first 3/4 of the film in a new light. I also think that watching Mulholland Falls for the first time is almost along these lines.
chaddyboy_2000: I'd say the second. I know no examples.
Lord_Prussian: I say always end with a bang, but I can't really give examples atm.
CortexBomb: I would say throughly engrossing throughout, if I'm spending my time I would rather have most of it be good and just the ending crap than vice versa. In that category the best example is Dark City, a fantastic movie with a throughly blah ending. In the boring but a good conclusion category I guess I would point to Star Wars: Episode I
CDRodeffer: I prefer the first type (Remains of the Day) much more than the second (The Medallion).