First |
Prev ||
Next |
Last
¿Question #5788?
Loquutus: Do you tink Puerto Rico is overrated?
Woelf: No, I would call it "underplayed". My copy, at least.
Knave: I tink so
ricardofo: nope
Obi Wann: never played it so can not answer that with any conviction
redsimon: I tink so (and I am sure a hundred other users made the same joke).
Firestata: Yes, beacuse its not my favourite game
Randy Cox: No.
vandemonium: Ti tink that teh tame tis totally tubular!
Spirit of 70: No.
otrex: Yes... it should be about a 6.5
arkibet: no
xofour: Maybe a little bit. Not horribly. I know a whole lot of people who just aren't into it. I have a particular fondness for it because it was the first game I had ever played with seperate boards and role selection so it was unlike any game I had ever played before. And it was fun. And so I think it deserves a high rating. But as I said I don't know that it necessarily deserves quite as high a rating as it has because it does not seem to be a concensus. But I have a small sample size so there is a good chance that I am skewed.
edarden: Not interested. Happy that others enjoy it.
Harkonnen13: Absolutely
mintylish: No.
jrbentley: Absolutely not, it's ranking is well-deserved.
bazik123: no. I don't think of it as highly, but everyone does enjoy it to some extent.
blindspot: Somebody's gotta be #1. Might as well be PR. You'd be asking the same question no matter what game was #1.
WonderLlama: No.
Wibblenut: Am guessing so, looks and sounds boring to me (it's a shopping game with wooden tokens... I'd rather play on eBay, at least I make real money)
bismarck1871: Haven't played it, unqualified to answer.
atrium: My leprechaun tinks it's overrated by tirty-tree and turd percent. diddly diddly dee, potato!
aleo09: maybe a little, but i like it
amievilyesiam666: I don tink so
sffh: yes, definitely
ZiggyZambo: don't know
jeffwolfe: Yes.
DHEK: No. It really is as good as they say it is.
kuchick: Eh. s'okay.
Butterbane: No ... that's where all the best rum is.
fxer: No, Puerto Rico actually was my first "real" board game I played. I've played many since, but PR is still top dog for me.
Der Ubermolch: Well, yes, because I think there are several games better. But it should be rated pretty highly, nonetheless.
Beelzebub: No
Leo-T: yes
GilvanBlight: Not at all, still my favouite game of all time.
BethR: Yes, I tink Puerto Rico is overrated.
bob_evans2020: I dont know
rawdawg: way
GornTC: I tink not.
Aljovin: Yes, but I've never played.
Timothius: I think so.
W Eric Martin: No.
bigbadsteve: i tink it could be
SisyphusX: Nope. I think many games are, however, underrated by comparison.
JonBen: no
kimizefa: No. It is THAT good.
Tailuje: I don't tink much, nowadays. Not since I lost my tinkerer's tools.
GuyHill: No
tim-pelican: Yes. Good, but over-rated - it's scripted with people who have played too much.
ibemichael: Havn't played it yet
marshalljansen: No.
MaksimSmelchak: Yes.
ststrat: yes
Chris Page: I _think_ it is.
scriptorum: I own it and I still haven't played it. I imagine it's not overrated though; some game has to be the most popular, why not PR?
mrspank: No.
djlg: Yes, it has way more ratings than almost all other games.
fehrmeister: No
CDRodeffer: WAY overrated.
puffinge: no, it belongs way up there, I'm just tired of it. And you are soooooo correct about the PR "experts" ruining this game for those of us who just want to enjoy it.
Felderin: I'm fairly certain that I have never "tinked" (tonked? tunk?).
Loquutus: Yes, I do tink tat. I also tink tat one of my keys is broken.
Odat: Nope.
chaddyboy_2000: Nope.
ssmooth: No, I tink it's that good.
jttm: Hehe... tink...
skelebone: I don't know, I've never played it.
Lord_Prussian: Not too much so. It's a great game.
sos1: Yes
CortexBomb: No, I think it's the game that the most people here can agree is at least good