First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #6130?
zadmando: Johnny Depp Willy Wonka or Gene Wilder Willy Wonka?

Jrtolf: Gene Wilder.
BOBBYCAN: Wonka's pretty popular around here, I see.
pricero1: I think the Depp version was much truer to the book.
parp: Gene Wilder of course
Jatoha: Gene Wilder
xofour: How is that even a question. Well, I know how it's a question, but it's so contemptuous that i'm not even going to dignify it with an non-answer.
the manatee: Gene Wilder. I love Depp, but his Wonka is just nuts. Wilder's Wonka is scamming ya the whole time.
Woelf: Gene Wilder's Wonka was more interesting because he was so sinister and borderline homicidal . Depp's was okay, but mostly just overly eccentric.
Blott: Gene Wilder Willy Wonka talking to Johnny Depp Willy Wonka: "YOU LOSE! GOOD DAY, SIR!
tankexmortis: I like them both immensely, and see no reason why they shouldn't coexist peacefully.
MajikMouse: Gene Wilder
The Unbeliever: 42
danweasel: Depp, it's closer to the book
Phil Fleischmann: The score so far is Wilder 26, Depp 7, Both (or something to that effect) 5, Neither 4. This question was asked again by someone else. I'm now going to check the responces to the other one and compare..
pwilz: Gene Wilder. Johnny Depp had poorer writers in my opinion.
spizio: Gene Wilder
Polgara: depp
Capt O: gene wilder
Farren: Gene Wilder.
alcbkr: Neither
Runehardt: Gene
jlavigne: Gene Wilder
gypsychk: Gene Wilder, by miles and miles.
DHEK: Neither. I've not seen the movie.
PopeBrain: gene
xlorp: No contest. Johnny Depp is many things but he is NOT funny like Gene Wilder.
ColtsFan76: Gene Wilder
clandaith: Johnny Depp. Damn he had some great lines and was just plain freaky.
Elf__Man: hard to say with directing differences
Ebon Wendigo: Gene Wilder
alligata: GENE WILDER
POvidiusNaso: Both have their glories. This is like comparing Joel Hodgson to Mike Nelson or Kirk to Picard.
AWildEep: GENE!
Galvatron: Johnny Depp.
dmomo: Both have strengths. I can't help but side with nostalgia
W Eric Martin: Depp.
Odat: Johnny Depp all the way. Nice and creepy, the way Wonka should be!
heavymetalhamster: Gene Wilder (But the new version Charlie is better)
Beelzebub: Gene Wilder
janiera: Gene Wilder
herman_the_german: Gene
XenoMaster: Gene Wilder
vampywife: i'm sure both have good qualities. i'm kinda partial to gene wilder as i grew up with that one
lauramath: that's a tough one, they both had merit
Loquutus: I would call it Tim Burton WW, not Johnny Depp. Actors are tools for the director.
Jim_P: JD
rawdawg: gene wilder
skrutsch: I haven't seen Johnny Depp's yet.
Lord_Prussian: Johnny Depp was very creepy. I was impressed.
shawn_low: Haven't seen Burton version but Gene Wilder was brilliant. He's a man possessed...I'm still frightened when I think about his performance.
Werebear: Am I ever glad I don't pay any attention any more. How many product crossovers? I can't even imagine
CDRodeffer: The latter.
skelebone: I've only seen the latter.
jasta6: no willy wonka
Randy Cox: Haven't seen (and probably won't) Depp, but Wilder wins anyway.
chaddyboy_2000: Gene Wilder.
jttm: Roald Dahl Willy Wonka
sos1: Gene Wilder