First |
Prev ||
Next |
Last
¿Question #6206?
puffinge: Do you know anyone who had great success being on the Atkins Diet? South Beach? Do you know anyone who got really sick from being on one of these diets? Please share.
Woelf: They all died and/or switched back to eating like normal people.
freechinanow: I haven't, though I am on a pretty low-carb diet myself I'm not sure of the specifics of the Atkins Diet or South Beach. I just don't eat gluten or foods with added sugars (natural or otherwise).
Caerid: No, no, no
Spirit of 70: No and no.
thoia: Yeah. A guy I knew did Atkins extreme. ONLY ate protien and the weight dropped off him. He'd eat like 2 pounds of bacon for breakfast and still lost over 100 pounds. I don't really know him anymore...I do kinda wonder if he's still alive though.
Kobold Curry Chef: No. No. No.
hob69: Yes. But it's unsustainable in the long term. Friend of mine got results all right, but he did slip back from it eventually and went on other sorts of fad things. Mind you, he works out too.
galenochfarlig: My mom actually lost 30 lbs while on atkins. Worked great for her.
cgund: My friend Chris did really well on that. But he was exercising a lot too.
Polgara: no, no
falloutfan: My buddy tried the Atkins. He lost weight but looked terrible. His complexion was pasty, and he had no energy. I wondered if it was really worth while considering the personal cost to his health.
earthvssoup: do you count congestive heart failure a "great success?"
ZiggyZambo: I lost about 40lbs on Atkins. But I couldn't stay on it because it is just so limiting. Quit and gained the weight back.
waza: No
mr. assist: lifestyle
bigbadsteve: none of the above
Muzza: no
POvidiusNaso: I lost 30 pounds on Atkins and got rid of my stomach trouble. Problem is that it's just as hard as any "celery and carrots" diet to keep up, though.
matthan: I don't know anyone who has had lasting success.
DHEK: I don't know anyone who has gone on any of those "fad" diets. Don't know of anyone who has gotten sick from a diet (regular or otherwise) either.
themagni: I had great success with the "bike to school" and "bike to work" diet. The secret to all weight loss is this: "Eat less. Exercise More." All these gimmick diets are just different ways of selling that same basic fact.
grafvolluth: I have had success with dietary tips from South Beach
aleo09: yes for atkins. don't know SB. no.
bluebehir: I don't even know the diets.
Inntrepid: I lost 30 pounds on Atkins but strayed off of it and gained the weight back. No, I do not know of anyone that sick.
Leo-T: Yes & yes. Low-carbs works, but as with EVERYTHING, in moderation. Nutrition must be maintained and the program must include regular cardiovascular work-outs.
scriptorum: I know several people who lost considerable weight from being on Atkins. None for South Beach. Nobody got sick from the diets, in fact they seemed to enjoy the extra protein.
brainrob: no, no and no
jasta6: I know two on Atkins, both put it all back on once they quit. Try Weight Watchers, it's the best one out there. Good food balance in this one. BUT you must exercise to make ANY diet work right!!.....
WatchmanX2000: yes
oceanika: Mom lost loads of weight on South Beach and is really thrilled - but spends her time at the grocery store and in the kitchen. I've never really seen any success in my circle from Atkins. He's a freak anyways.
djlg: No. No. No. Most people I know don't abuse themselves that much.
skrutsch: Yes (Mom), Yes (husband), No. My Mom lost lots of weight to improve her quality of life. Then she died suddenly from an unrelated problem. I always hate that she spent the last year of her life not eating foods she enjoyed.
Lord_Prussian: I've seen swings in weight but it went both ways. I don't know of any permanent changes. I don't know of anyone getting sick.
Colorado: Diets may work in the short term or occasionally, but a balanced diet with reasonable portions and exercise is the only way to go.
CDRodeffer: Yes, yes, no and no, thank you.
skelebone: I lost about 35 lbs. on Atkins, and was seeing progress with South Beach before my diet went into the toilet during the house move.
chaddyboy_2000: Atkins, successful, but the person started feeling not so hot.
CortexBomb: No, no, no...the people I hang out with are thankfully immune to fad diets
Randy Cox: I met a big-ass fat guy at a Come-To-Wal-Mart meeting and he said he'd lost over 150 pounds. He was on the verge of keytosis, I'm sure, though. South Beach is actually sustainable. Atkins is not. Talk to insurance agents about getting past the medical screening if you're on Atkins.
jttm: Nope