First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #6210?
puffinge: Does the RIAA have a valid argument when they say music sales are down due to illigal downloading?

ocdspectrum: I am against illigals.
Cordwangle: No
Woelf: Thanks Obama!
vinceq: absolutely. their conclusions about what to do about it, however....
Scrat: Difficult to answer absolutely as cost of purchasing music have gone up. If costs remained constant, then you have a baseline to draw the conclusion from.
Tirpen: Kind of. The problem is that it was so much easier to get the music illegally than legaly for a very, very long time. Then people got stuck in their ways. Now adays most of the people I know use legal alternatives (Spotify).
pakruse: No
Felimid: Nope. I agree with Illiad's (creator of "User Friendly" comic strip) position on it. RIAA is shooting itself in the foot and until it wakes up and rejoins reality it will continue to shoot itself in the foot. This does not mean I think illegal downloading is the solution ... it isn't. Legal downloading, however, shouldn't be that difficult to set up. For instance, the iTune store doesn't seem to be hurting, earnings-wise ... but I wish its selection of synthesizer music were alot better.
kingofthegrill: very valid. Go bit torrents. All kidding aside, I think it has become a major problem for the RIAA. I'm lazy so I just use Itunes. I don't even have to leave my desk.
atrium: no, sales are down due to recording artists being crap
daveroswell: Music sales are down because of the radio, MTV, being able to listen to music on commercials, and yeah some downloaded stuff (but it's not as pronounced as they would like you to believe
spayne: yes
kingmaker fan: Yes, but no where near to the extent they claim. Most who are downloading weren't going to buy anyway.
ahauwi1: Only if those downloaders would otherwise have made purchases at market prices set by RIAA. Demand might be down for any number of reasons (i.e. due to lower-quality product being output, competition with other entertainment sources like social networking, the fact that most albums have only had one or two good tracks anyway and now we can but those tracks piecemeal instead of having to buy 12 bad/soso songs to get 1 or 2 good ones, etc...)
Nikku: No. They will burn in hell.
abrannan: Yes, but not nearly to the extent that they claim. Every download is not a lost sale.
Zedsdead: I doubt that illegal downloading is the main culprit for slow music sales. Blame it on high prices and low quality.
WatchmanX2000: no
Osiris Ra: No, they are evil scum. Evil scum, I say.
RaDiKal: No, sales are down due to the value proposition the music industry offers.
DKahnt: yes
Letz Teemup: It may be valid reason why, but doesn't mean it's wrong.
Ludocrazy: Yes
Warbanner: Even if they're correct (which they may not be), the conclusions they draw from it are shaky.
BethR: No. illigal, is that a spelling bee word?
DHEK: I think they do, but I'm sure it is at least slightly exaggerated (to their advantage, of course).
TheArchAngel: no, cause people have been sharing for years. Its the price they are charging that's killing sales
aleo09: no
Geosphere: 100%
Brentoon: I could agree with that, but I think people should be allowed to download music
Frodd: yes
POvidiusNaso: How the hell would I know?
mats-k: No.
ZiggyZambo: Yes.
purvisa: Not with evidence they have yet provided. At this time it is merely post hoc argumentation.
stevegamer: Statement is valid.
KentuckyKid: Yes, but in general, copyright law is going to have to be reevaluated in terms of the new technologies available.
MisterCranky: Does your mother have a valid argument when she says that she never liked you?
Helenoftroy: most likely. Teenagers can choose what they listen to through the internet. Now the industry does choose for them. illegal is bad but there has to be give on both sides.
BobMaysJr: I don't doubt that they're down very slightly due to illegal downloads, but my belief is that sales are down because they're asking way too much money for way too little quality music on the CDs.
pattonre: Yes
falloutfan: I think that there is some truth to this - at least from a statistical standpoint. However, I think it's probably not as much as they say. (By a long shot)
jasta6: yes..................................
SkyBry: No, not really.
rhysling: No. Especially for me. I've bought about $20 in iTunes this year so far and that's it for music.
Joanna Olsen: No
Jim_P: Yes
djlg: Well the only other reason for sales to be down is the amount of crap they put out.
mrbeankc: No
ctalbot: No.
skrutsch: Maybe. I don't have the data.
Lord_Prussian: No, not as long as they keep selling the same product at the same price and offer nothing new for a decade or more. CD's are a nearly outmoded product. It's no wonder that sales are down. They should've started selling MP3's way sooner for a buck a song. Also, cut prices on cd's to 9.99 or less. DVD's have been taking the market share, not file sharing.
Tushratta: Sort of. But a lot of the new music sucks--that must have something to do with it.
CDRodeffer: No. But even if that argument were valid, it would make me support the downloaders even more. Overthrow the overlords!
Cavedog_pdx: Illegal downloading is a symptom of a problem not the real problem itself. The problem is the music industry is operating much as it did 50 years ago. The times have moved on but they haven't figured out how to adapt yet.
bigbadsteve: no, they should listen to some of the new releases out there
skelebone: I don't believe so, because they can't establish a causal relationship. And actually, the RIAA saw bumper years of sales within the last 5 in spite of all the downloading.
heli: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/4718249.stm
puffinge: hahahahahahahahahahaha
ssmooth: I think that's factually correct, but what's their argument?
chaddyboy_2000: Probably.
CortexBomb: I would say so
vetinari7878: Not really.
Randy Cox: Not really. Not that many music listeners are so wired and tech savvy to do that Napster thing and many who will download wouldn't purchase anyway--so it's not a lost sale. May be unethical, but not derailing the market.
jttm: *snigger* illigal?
DaGen: no, not in my case! I still buy as much cds as ever, My to buy list is just bigger now!
Loquutus: No, for several reasons. A cd costs next to nothing to make and they have been ripping us off and living high for years. Secondly, they are lying, record sales are up. It is disgusting when millionaires whine that they don't make enough money.