First |
Prev ||
Next |
Last
¿Question #6228?
Loquutus: Can you tell the difference between winning a game by luck and winning by skill? Which do you think wins more often?
Woelf: Yes; skill wins more often overall, but wins due to luck tend to be more memorable.
Gerdion: Luck wins games more often - but only because I play more luck-centric games.
Narlgoth: Dice.
ArseFez: Can you tell the difference between Bruce Wayne and Batman?
Marechallannes: There is no difference. A victory is a victory. Even the best player has to accept, that luck is part of the game.
Blott: Totally depends on the game and the way the luck is created.
dlaurent: skill
Spirit of 70: It depends on the game.
Felimid: Hopefully winning by skill. Games that can only be won by luck wouldn't be anywhere near as interesting.
BeeCeeJay: Yes. As the saying goes, "I'd rather be lucky than good." I don't play lots of luck-driven games, though, so I think skill wins more.
IdahoGeekette: Yes, I can, because I can tell if I the choices I made led to those conditions. I think both come into play, but some games leave more room for some options than others.
rhackler: Yes. The short answer to the second question is: "It depends."
Hendal: Yes, depends on which game we are talking about
whac3: Yes. depends on the game
Puquak: More often for every game ever played? Not sure, but for me it would definately be more luck.
Volksturm: Skill, hands down
Thegreatrob: skill wins more often, but lucky win you remember more
KnobDoctor: well that depends on the rules of the game
blan86: Skill
DHEK: Of course I can tell a difference! Skill wins more often, of course, unless the game is highly luck-based.
themagni: Luck is simply the combination of preparation and opportunity.
White Stone: Yes. Skill.
Cordingley: It's usually a little of both, but people with skill tend to win the most.
vampywife: Yes. It depends on the game, really. If it's a totally luck-based game, of course you're going to win by luck, where as if it's a total strategy game, it's most likely the skill that wins.
clandaith: Yes. Depends on the game mechanics involved.
Slickfishe: Yes. It depends on the game. Luck can only go so far.
gf_ripper: yes, depends on the game.
POvidiusNaso: Yes. Luck.
PsyJam: How much luck in chess? It depends on the game, but I think when luck is involved, it always plays a significant role.
unifex: Yes. Depends on the game mechanics.
erikk: Unless it's a very simple game, you make your own luck through skillful uses of what's given to you
Greedo: In Magic, if both players are experienced, I find that skill beats luck about 70% of the time.
Michelle0070: If I win, it is luck. My bf kicks my ass all the time, and it is no fun at all for me, or for him.
KDSN: luck
GornTC: Skill wins out. Luck doesn't exist. Probability does.
scriptorum: Aren't you referring to standard deviation in statistics?
bigbadsteve: usually you can. probably skill.
dmomo: Depends on the game.
Dorque: Yup. Luck.
FrozenHoHos: Yes. Skill (unless were talking about LCR)
ststrat: yes. depends on the game.
LemonyFresh: Skill always wins
brainrob: Yes ... turn order can help in a close game
skrutsch: It's usually a bit of each.
_Kael_: Yes. Me, due to the first
Lord_Prussian: Yes, but it certainly is possible to confuse the two. Depends on the game, but if there is any skill at all, it will win the day over enough plays.
CDRodeffer: It depends upon the game.
skelebone: Skill is more apt to repeated wins.
CortexBomb: Um yes. And what?
chaddyboy_2000: Skill probably wins more often in a skill based game, while luck will win more often in a lucj based game.
jttm: Depends on the game
Dave: Winning by manipulating your opponents.