First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #2822?
Tim Synge: Carcassonne with or without the river expansion?

rayzg: Without.
Blazur: I enjoy using it on occasion.
Pomozzi: Without unless you are playing with all of the expansions in a huge game.
Felimid: With.
Woelf: With... sometimes.
ricardofo: with
Jatoha: I've only played it with the river
Ykikamucow: With. But without the catapult expansion.
thoia: Man I have river, and 2 copies of River 2. Not to mention 2 of the Mini expansions so I can have the tile with the lake that has the road.
pooterbug: Either way really. I like both.
FieldMarshalGames: Never to many expansions... More expansions!
rseater: river is better
obo55: With
cgund: I've only ever played Hunters and Gatherers.
Frubgarde: Without.
1000rpm: With
Pallet Ranger: with
DHEK: Dunno. Never played it with or without the expansion.
ColtsFan76: with both Rivers
rootbeer: Either way.
Geosphere: Mine came with it, never played without
onky: Without.
mpw182: with
LordT: With river
ellephai: Probably with, but I don't feel strongly about it.
WalkerRedEye: not played it im leaning towards hunters and gatherers as it supposedly has amammoth in it, does that have ariver
SisyphusX: With.
xandryyte: Either way is fine with me...
Dorque: With.
Nekura: Haven't tried it with yet
brainrob: With
Shotmagnet: sure, why not?
Chris Page: With. The board looks prettier that way.
The Unbeliever: 42
Dreamshadow: With.
Gamesmeister99: with
davidwpa: with
orodreth: Rivers ALWAYS... uhm Hunters & Gatherers, hehe
fubar awol: Carc's not my thing
Kazin: I've only ever played hunters and gatherers, so yes, with rivers...
javelin98: With.
Loquutus: How about I throw Carcassonne in the river? With all the expansions.
Recneps: Depends on the moment.
POvidiusNaso: Without. The early farmer can be a killer.
shizzane: neither
scriptorum: I'll let you know when I try the river expansion.
Igloo cool: Without
Mark Smith: I've only ever played it with.
GuyHill: without
Jim_P: With
Null Signature: Both are good, if you need my vote i'll go without.
Longbow: with!
Thedalek: Without.
Jeshko: typically without, although i don't mind it once in awhile
Legend Dan: With.
2amp: never played
matthew.marquand: The river tiles add nothing of interest
Lord_Prussian: With is ok
BaSL: without
johnkerr: Without.
AdamT: Never really tried it as I can't seem to print it out at the same size as the original tiles.
davedanger: neither
skrutsch: Either way.
Redneon: With
tempus42: Without.
djlg: Without thanks.
dcgogo: with
fehrmeister: With - I like fighting over the big farm it creates
stephensj23: without
heli: river's good
SteveK2: without
puffinge: To me there's not much difference. It's an ok game with or without.
ValJor: My version is the original one, without it. I had to print it and assemble myself.
shumyum: without
Randy Cox: Carcassonne without any tiles.
jttm: Definitely without
snoozefest: either
CortexBomb: I prefer no Carcassonne
Tim Synge: With.
skelebone: River every time.
chaddyboy_2000: With.
CDRodeffer: With
Spielfreak: without