First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #3262?
darthcliff: Does Episode III make up for Episode I?

GeoffreyB: Yes
BOBBYCAN: Voodoo was not part of Star Wars, as I recall.
Lord_Prussian: Only if you hold me like you did by the lake on Naboo... so long ago when there was nothing but Star Wars, Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi....No Episode I, II or III...when Han Solo shot first. Ok, yah, there *were* Ewoks, and it should have been Revenge of the Jedi...that was the start of it all... way to go and spoil a great memory...Thanks! Sheesh!
pwilz: Harry Potter never got really bad, though Order of the Phoenix is easily the worst movie.
Timber2wolf: I know not of what you speak. The only Episodes I know of is IV, V, and VI.
Blazur: Hardly.
the manatee: Not fully.
Jbrady: No
Phil Fleischmann: No.
Felimid: Depends on how often you get depressed. :)
Blott: Not really.
Woelf: Maybe for some of the whiners? I liked all three.
xTHAWx: Up until the part where Vader screams "Noooooooooooo!" I'd say yes. Even though Hayden Christensen's acting sucks...
daveroswell: No
Hector Vortac: Episode III of the OJ trial? Alan Iverson? The Bush presidency? A Phil Helmuth poker tournament?
BobbyChicken: Episode I wasn't bad, just a bit slow
projectmatter: no!!
BartowWing: Absolutely not
Steerpike.Instance: both are pants
ColtsFan76: unfortunately, no
vampywife: I liked Episode I, thank you :P
Chris Page: I don't know. After Epsiode I, I was too terrified about what I might get burned onto my retina in III.
Boot2daHead: Did Jar-Jar die a horrible, painful death? Then 'no'.
ironsizide: No
bigbadsteve: yeah
consolewa: Lucas made out on both.
Justin77: Does my answering this question make up for you asking it?
DHEK: Actually I think Episode I wasn't that bad. Episode II was undeniably the worst of the three, though.
OsmiumATOMasATOM: No. Certain things cannot be reversed.
Zelurs: No. In fact if you watch the episode 1 and 3 blindfolded and ears stuffed, 1 is way much better. But seriously, 3 had too large boots to fill so it failed miserably even if it sometimes slightly touched the feel of the originals. If you forget minichlorines, Jar-Jar, Anakin and stupid droids, episode I is more Star Wars than ep3.
Onionking: Yes.
Stas: Hell no.
Grungydan: No. All of them are terrible.
aleo09: absolutely
jeffwolfe: haven't seen it
Numskull: NOTHING makes up for Episode I.
martybjsg: Partially
dsmeyer: Yes, but not Episode 2
Ebon Wendigo: Not really
pkreynolds: Somewhat. But Episode IV makes up for all of the prequels.
Greedo: Yes.
StevieA: Never
Lightstorm: no no no no
SisyphusX: Episode I doesn't need making up for. EP3 is better than EP1, but the duel end in EP3 is what the rest of EP3 makes up for.
Karmic_devil: A lifetime of episode 3s can never undo the damage of Jar Jar Binks.
jasta6: No, Episode I is still one of the best...................................................................................................................................................
crimsonking: Yes
Mojo Jojo: Not by a long way
brainrob: No
orodreth: No
ctalbot: No.
LemonyFresh: No
scriptorum: Whee, Star Wars questions!!
Loquutus: No, but Empire did.
acetate3: I don't know, I stopped watching halfway through Episode II.
Excalabur: Somewhat. But not for Jar-Jar
darthcliff: Not really. Taking George Lucas outside and flogging him might make up for Episode I.
ZombyDawg: Are you talking about episodes of the Flying Nun?
POvidiusNaso: No. Let's be honest, most of Episode III was just the same. They should have trashed all of the first three episodes except for the last half-hour or so of #3.
Null Signature: episode I needed no making up for...Episode II on the other hand...
Ludocrazy: Nope. No. Not at all. No.
Reloaded: haven't seen III yet, but I sucked the nut big time so that bar is raised super freaking high...
arkibet: nope.
ValJor: I haven't seen Episode III yet
Belash: the real question is does it make up for both Episode I AND II... and that I do not think it does... but DAMN was it good!
skrutsch: I haven't seen either.
snoozefest: no
djlg: No. Nothing could make up for any of EP1, EP2 or EP3.
2amp: never saw
jttm: Yes
puffinge: Uhoh I think Chaddy and Phil are ready to blow.
heli: n
CortexBomb: No, but it does make up for Episode II, which is much, much worse than Episode I
The Unbeliever: 42
skelebone: Yes. No. I don't know. Who gives a shit?
CDRodeffer: HOT LAVA DEATH!
Spielfreak: Bleep. Bleep.
chaddyboy_2000: Bleep.