First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #3853?
TaliaIsabelle: Expansions: Yay or Nay?

ocdspectrum: Usually yay.
Woelf: Yay for games that need them, nay for games that don't.
Paradox Games: ME: yay. My wallet: nay
vandemonium: Yay sometimes, nay others.
the manatee: Yay.
Grayle84: Yay
teambrodudeski: If I liked the original games I'll buy the expansions.
Turbine2k5: YAY!
meijerc: yay
Kev. d: Yay!
MisterCranky: John Henry reminds you, "Only YOU can join COLA!"
Zwecklos: Yay!
Komodo: yay
senorcoo: Yay-yaaaaaay (said with a Dirty South accent).
interhawk: nay, not good enough to be part of the base game, not good enough period
jessitron: yay
hob69: yay
Polgara: nay
jajax: Nes
2amp: Yay
agentlars: YAY
Azog: Depends on the game.
Wes Hope: YAY
Chazar: Depends: Nay for player number expansions; Yay for expansions that bring new ideas to the game, which the designer did not think of originally (or which the puplisher thought were not accetaple to the audience).
CrispyFries: Yay
Megadev: YAY!!!!! Expansions YAY!!! I've got expansions!! YAY!!!!
chockle: Some games don't need expansions. Sometimes the expansions come out before being properly tested, which really ruins it for me.
Puddle: Yay
kingmaker fan: Yay
DarqueKhaos: yay - mostly
DHEK: Yay
elirlandes: Like everything else, there are fine examples and awful examples.
aleo09: depends. cities and knights = yay. Carc = too many to count
Leo-T: depends on the game - usually yay
Ebon Wendigo: Yay!
Brentoon: yay I say, but what the hay lets just play
Majiken: I exercise to avoid expansion.
POvidiusNaso: Depends on the game.
airborne101: yay
Gamegrunt: Generally, Nay.
Capitaine Grappin: YAY
mpw182: yay
Dryfus: yay
AWildEep: Nay
htp1: Yay
alfons: yay or nay - depends
rawdawg: deffinitly
Philip Thomas: Yea
tranzducer: YAAAAY !!
Thesp: Yay!
HScottBuck: Yay
Beelzebub: Yay
SisyphusX: Yay!
dmomo: Nay
brainrob: Depends on the game / expansion
kgm3219: yay
vampywife: It depends on the expansion, some are worthy, some are milking the gaming cow.
Avatar_69: Yea (as it is correctly spelled), but limit it to one expansion per game
PsyJam: Yay!
Winter Wolf: If the expansion content is worthy of the price tag then yes. (Frag looks like a bad example)
Chris Page: And then some.
orodreth: Yay!
dietevil: Nay, for the most part
Janiv: Yay!
korppu: Yay and Nay, depends on the game
skrutsch: Yay, usually.
Tennantgamer: depends on how well they are made--a lot are very well thought out but by the 27 expansion I can assure you the good ideas are long gone
Adiegirl: Yay! Yay! yay!
Recneps: Yay to a point.
Jim_P: Yay
BaSL: May
puffinge: more often nay
scriptorum: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/question/3852
djlg: Nay... usually.
Lord_Prussian: Nay
GuyHill: in general: Nay
matthew.marquand: depends
jttm: Obviously it depends
mrbeankc: Yay
CortexBomb: Most often good, sometimes a waste, sometimes wreck the game
chaddyboy_2000: Yay if the base game is any good.
CDRodeffer: Sure.
skelebone: Once again, since it's all so black and white for every expansion ever created, I'll stick with black.
Spielfreak: Nay