First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #56?
Karlsen: What flavour Cosmic Encounter is best? Eon, Mayfair or Avalon Hill?

oldhoss: Don't know any of them.
Woelf: Cherry or raspberry
beerbear: I'd love to play this game some time.
resin: Mayfair, but I admit that I don't really know them that well.
Varduk: Avalon hill
bcooperok: Eon!
Spirit of 70: Eon.
nonnymouse: I've been informed by a gaming friend who's familiar with all three that Eon is the best followed by Mayfair, so I stand corrected
vandemonium: Vanilla.
LeZerp: dunno
cgund: Have never played.
syphon: Mayfair.
zeruf: DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDUUUUUUUUUUUUHHHHHHH
DroppEcho: Eon rules, AH production (apart from the mothership and transport). Prediction: FFG version will blow them all away in terms of rules and bits.
aleo09: never played
StuartMc: They're all a bit poor to be honest
DHEK: I've not even played the game before, so I can't say.
cowdog: It's all good
animal: No contest: Kirk. Er...I mean Eon.
Cut & Space: Don't know
interhawk: ??
Mecoides: Eon. Avalon Hill sucks nuts.
Avatar_69: Mayfair
Dorque: Chocolate with caramel and oreos.
jasta6: TAHGC.............................
rootbeer: My homemade one. Which is mostly based on Eon.
Chris Page: Eon, followed by Mayfair.
bigbadsteve: i am an ah fan
pkreynolds: I don't like any of them.
brainrob: I don't like any of them
stray_flux: Have only played one so can't say.
Great Dane: They all suck!
LemonyFresh: Mayfair
xlorp: Mayfair
javelin98: AH
Belash: All of the above
GrandpaDave: *Shrug*
Rukasu: I wish I knew...
heli: only played the original
davedanger: eon
redhuntingcap: i've never played any version of that game.
skrutsch: You forgot West End! (Mayfair is best in our opinion.)
Sceadeau: Avalon Hill is the one I own, and I like it
CapAp: AH is the only one I've ever played.
Lord_Prussian: Eon
scriptorum: Whichever one is sitting on my shelf.
Windopaene: Only played Eon, so it wins by default
snoozefest: AH pieces, mayfair cards; haven't seen eon
filou: Vanilla
Jern: Only tried Mayfair
gnomehome: I haven't played all versions.
hpox: Never played :(
RandallPeek: I own all three versions. Mayfair is the cleanest, but Eon appeals to the purist in me. AH is by far the lesser of the options. If I had to pick, Mayfair.
Mark_WH: Eon
Randy Cox: Well, "best" is a superlative, so none is the answer. But which is least offensive? Eon.
puffinge: nooooooooooooooooooo
Bearcat89: I've only played Mayfair.
UhhhClem: Eon.
filnari: Mayfair
solove: Games Workshop... better than all three together
Chris Schreiber: (have never played CE)
mrbeankc: AH
Spielfreak: AH
fsumarc: chocolate. sorry don't own it.
Blackwind: The one I own.
CortexBomb: If I were going to sit down with it I would prefer Eon for variability
DangerMouse: Mayfair
onky: Avalon
Ebon Wendigo: Eon
chaddyboy_2000: Burn them all!
geberus: ?
djlg: Vanilla
BobDodgerBlue: I like Mayfair, but that is the one that I mostly played
djflippy: Eon
dakarp: I played a lot of Mayfair, and liked it. Avalon Hill is not as good, but I don't know about Eon.
Critical Mass: caramel
Eric Haas: I've only played the Mayfair version.
Jim_P: Eon
Rubric: Eon, of the choices given. But the best thing is making your own flavors.
MisterCranky: I think we can eliminate Avalon Hill right away. And then, because the Mayfair edition entangled me in a seemingly neverending flamewar on Usenet, I will vote for Eon.
berserkley: eon
janiera: Never played
skelebone: Pistacio.
Xlyce: Mayfair
EYE of NiGHT: Settlers.
CDRodeffer: Homemade
AnakinOU: Anything with extraneous U's
IngredientX: Forgive me, I just could never get into CE.
Linnaeus: Haven't played CE, and I'm not sure it's my cup of tea.
fanaka66: Never played
Zambogirl: None
Flyspeck23: Vanilla.
sumo: Eon
The Maverick: Eon!
Septic: Eon. 'cause I'm so old
Fawkes: Yuck, yuck and yuck.
LudesFactor: Eon
ynnen: Mayfair + More Cosmic - Lucre ...
manowarplayer: Mayfair by far. The timing rules greatly simplified the game.
Shakar: I Only know the AH one.
DrVital: Mayfair
hooded_paladin: My favorite would be playing Avalon Hill with all the features of Eon. Hence, kitbashing.
ValJor: I only played AH and didn't like it.
midnightferret: Avalon Hill
ping9x: Mayfair, only because I haven't played Eon
Aldie: I only know Mayfair... so Mayfair.
jttm: No idea.