First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #57?
fteplin: Settlers or Settlers + expansions?

oldhoss: One of the 5-6 player expansions. That way everyone can play at my in-laws.
Raujour: Neither... not a Settlers fan
Narlgoth: No.
imyourskribe: On my game table? A different game. On yours, I'd recommend base so the game is shorter.
Woelf: Sure, but only if we have enough people to make it a 4-player game.
cowboycw: i love a good expantion
ZeroZilla: Yes, please. Cities and Knights, for preference...but I'll play straight up, and enjoy the game.
beerbear: Why do I live in a cave and eat what i can catch and find? Cause I'm going back to the basics, Babe.
resin: whichever is over faster so I can get to a game I actually want to play.
bcooperok: Expanding lets me play with friends, but too much expansion and we feel bloated.
xofour: If i've got to play it, then probably just the basic game.
JohnBandettini: Settlers
cgund: neither
gmcash: either
DKahnt: C&K
logicalgambit: Settlers + expansions
kdiddy13: Honestly, I've never played Settlers.
KrisVerbeeck: +expansions + the option to leave expansions out
DHEK: Settlers + expansions.
Benzebub: Both.
travellerne: Usually just Settlers for me.
monkeyrobot: Settlers.
aleo09: cities & knights
Beelzebub: S+e
drsingle: Settlers
W Eric Martin: Settlers.
mooka: Settlers + expansions
everlong205: Settlers
brainrob: None - they are all overrated
Cromaa: Expansions
Kyralia: 50/50
Dorque: 2
FrozenHoHos: Expansions
JasonMatthews: Settlers or better, no Settlers at all.
crimsonking: Settlers
Stinger: Settlers
ralpheous: settlers
Chris Page: Either/or.
arkibet: I've owned Cities and Knights since it came out, and it has NEVER BEEN PLAYED! :(
Great Dane: expansions, expansions, expansions!!!!
Kazin: As many expansions as possible.
locusshifter: Both...I'll take my Settlers straight up or on the rocks....I like it either way
ecliptik: straight up beotch
Loquutus: Vanilla is best.
POvidiusNaso: Settlers.
puzzleme: Settlers. Never the 5-6 player expansions - too much luck dependant.
SteveK2: settlers, but sometimes + cities & knights
Null Signature: Settlers
ConraDargo: Settlers The Card Game
Megadev: Expansions all the way, but I wouldn't be opposed to mixing in a basic game now and then.
chux vomitus: Settlers
thoia: 5-6 player exp.
skrutsch: Either
Redneon: Settlers (5-6 player only)
Lord_Prussian: Settlers of Stone Age
davedanger: Wall of China IS THE BEST.
ssmooth: Settlers. Settlers of Nuremberg sometimes.
r3gamer: settlers + CK only
TaliaIsabelle: Settlers
Scott Tepper: neither
scriptorum: More is better
mandj2001: + expansions
abimilech: I won't settle.. we're going to take this puppy to court!
Ivan: Settlers.
heli: let's play!
2amp: never played
Claytonius Maximus: Vanilla
SusanRoz: Settlers + Seafarers
GuyHill: settlers + 5/6
m_r_tyler: Vanilla settlers
Peregrine: Settlers
isolated: How long do you want to play?
Dave: If I had to choose? I'd go with the Buch for the variety.
AlorielLelyn: Expansions, definitely. Seafarers adds sooo much.
fizzix: Cities and knights is a necessity.
shippert: Settlers
Oborro: expansions
kennyb: I have to admit i dont have any of the expansions ...yet!!!
netfilterz: I like it better with I think...
TG Mittler: settlers
nnf1: Settlers
CDRodeffer: I'm happy to play either.
Blackwind: Settlers
fsumarc: I have none...
Nightmare: Settlers + expansions
puffinge: settlers
chaddyboy_2000: Settlers
onky: + exp.
geberus: seefaheren
Belash: Knights and Cities
BobDodgerBlue: Settlers
Michael Becker: basic settler please
markk415: Settlers
djflippy: Both
TragicHeroBC: I've only played it by itself.
raolsson: Settlers
louiseh: Vanilla
Ludocrazy: Settlers
loonling: how about starship -- does that count?
dbmurph22: cities and knights
Glamorous Mucus: Seafarers, or just base game. No C&K, no 5-6 players.
falcala: Settlers
Denise: Plain ol' Settlers
richardolen2: Settlers.
queequeg: Settlers
djlg: Neither. But if forced, I'd prefer with Seafarers, but no other expansions.
dakarp: Settlers
hooded_paladin: Expansions.
BeyondMonopoly: Vanilla
pernishus: Gotta have more settlers expansions
seppo21: Settlers (w/ 5 & 6 player expansion when necessary)
Gelatinous Goo: vanilla
Mike A: Settlers.
berserkley: Settlers
Jim_P: Cities and Knights (4 player only)
shumyum: Settlers
shotokanguy: Settlers plus Seafarers
AnakinOU: Expansions are good.
Sky Knight X: Settlers + Seafarers
daw65: Totally depends on the situation. I like both options.
snoozefest: settlers or knights; not seafarers
nix342: Cities & Knights
rochs77: Settlers solo
Spielguy: Settlers and variety
Donkey Thong: Settlers + Seafarers
dietevil: Settlers
BaSL: Settlers+\
Zambogirl: I haven't tried expansions
PopeBrain: Vanilla
Vince Londini: Cities and Knights w/o Seafarers
skelebone: Settlers.
Friendless: Settlers + different games
Drewcooter: Just plain Settlers
Geosphere: Neither.
bard: Settlers Vanilla please.
Ryno8: Settlers + expansions
walk_softly: both - they each have their value.
WasQ: settlers + expansion (seafarers)
Jon_1066: Vanilla
fnord23: + expansions
Flyspeck23: The latter.
Debate: Dull without the expansions
gnomehome: Expansions !
Fawkes: Yuck either way.
bbenston: Vanilla Settlers
MikeMKH: None of the above
CortexBomb: Settlers, expansions make the game too long / too not what it was meant to be
manowarplayer: Cities & Knights or else it's something else.
ynnen: Neither... Give me Starfarers of Catan over Settlers any day of the week.
janiera: Settlers
ensor: Settlers
darquil: Settlers
HBGlover: Settlers is best in its pure form.
Karlsen: Settlers
Shakar: Settlers.
tiredmind: Settlers
ValJor: Just the basic
rkalajian: Settlers
ping9x: Settlers by itself is enough torture.
Aldie: Cities & Knights
jttm: Expansions!