First | Prev || Next | Last
¿Question #786?
TomVasel: Star Destroyer vs. Enterprise. Which would win?

ocdspectrum: Enterprise would run away like a Monty Python skit.
LoupSolitaire: https://boardgamegeek.com/image/4828134/loupsolitaire
imyourskribe: Star destroyer
OmegaII: The black hole next to it.
Felimid: Imperial Star Destroyer.
the manatee: Star Destroyer.
cervantes3773: Star Destoryer - in addition to powerful weapons, it can launch a fleet of support craft (fighters and bombers, etc)
Spirit of 70: Enterprise. The Enterprise has much better shields and can destroy a planet (see episode 'Arena' from the original series).
Niediam: Cleary Star Destroyer.
Septic: ENTERPRISE!
ricardofo: Enterprise. The man, not the machine
Germflinger: Enterprise. Star Destroyers never seem to do anything.
Woelf: The 1701-E would probably come out ahead and the -D might if it got a little lucky, but none of the older versions would stand a chance unless they cheated somehow. If it was an Executor-class (Super) instead of a standard Star Destroyer they'd all be screwed.
kathleenryan: The Enterprise
jp21763: enterprise
stormwaffle: Star Destroyer
gmonk: I don't know anything about the Which, but if it helped the Enterprise they'd both get their asses handed to them on a plate.
Head_Rat: Serenity.
DKahnt: Enterprise
Zarion of Arabel: star destroyer
Khabbi: Enterprise
Cross_: Can't compare since they are in different universes. How effective is a phaser against that destroyer? Will it bounce off the hull or slice it like butter?
ckotchey: Star Destroyer - much larger, more guns, and full of fighters.
aleo09: SD
ATeamRules: In a beauty contest, neither would be able to wear the swimsuit. Ms NW Antrtica wins by a nose.
kjdaiisha: Star Destroyer, like Star Trek is real?
papa_bear_is_asleep: It depends on who gets to write the script.
warpozio: Star Destroyer
bluebehir: Star Destroyer.
DHEK: Star Destroyer of course. Come on, it's like way bigger and powerful than the Enterprise...
Royalflush: Which Enterprise??
Quixote171: Is Lord Vader on board? I think he might sway the battle.
dsmeyer: ICSD would dominate. In fact I think a VCSD would to
_Kael_: Star Destroyer. Build for killing, not exploration.
Greedo: Holy cow! The Star Destroyer would obliterate the Enterprise.
KentuckyKid: Enterprise. I've seen ST enough to know that.
scriptorum: Enterprise, only because they've got transport technology and can beam torpedos into the Star Destroyer main bridge willy nilly.
TKRKS: Star Destroyer
Leo H: Star Destroyer. It's huge!
TaliaIsabelle: Star Wars
waddball: SD all the way. Enterprise is too creaky.
Dweeb: A Star Destroyer is described as unrealistically large. This isn't a fair fight.
frieque: Star Destroyer
jaycdu: Enterprise, its faster
brainrob: Don't care
ciscokidnj: enterprise sadly
hellsbishop: Star Destoyer.
hkishel: Star Destroyer
Chris Page: I don't know, but either way the laws of physics lose bigtime.
Grizzley91: star destroyer
klellingson: Star Destroyer
ptsuk: Star Destroyer........they carry fighters too.....lots and lots of fighters...
vetinari7878: The Star Destroyer is bigger, but the Enterprise crew is smarter. If it is just a "generic" ISD, I'd go with the Enterprise.
chrisisapimp: star destroyer duh
DaGen: Enterprise
Loquutus: Star Destroyer.
RoSKoMaNTe: enterprise
gamesbook: Enterprise
POvidiusNaso: Star Destroyer.
Suzan: Enterprise
Larry Chong: Depends on who's commanding which. Vader vs. Picard...? Probably, Vader, but I'd root for Picard. "Jean Luc, . . . I am your father...!" :)
Legend Dan: Enterprise would just make shit up.
CharlieWonka: Enterprise - it has Worf
skrutsch: I'll have to go with Enterprise. I don't know the Star Destroyer, but it does sound dangerous.
Megadev: Enterprise, there's just too many dumb stormtroopers on a Star Destroyer
Lord_Prussian: Star Destroyer
wildcatterry17: the death star
The Unbeliever: 42
Skipthis86: Star Destroyer. Duh! Star trek is just a tv show.
meshuggener: The Enterprise would be a smoking glob of space-gas in about two seconds.
Bearcat89: Depends upon which Enterprise and which Captain.
silverthorn11: Enterprise
AWildEep: Enterprise. A star destroyer was taken out by single fighter running into it. Star Destroyer has more cool points though.
2amp: had this arguement years ago. enterprise could beam several nukes onto the cheese wedge & blow it to smitherinees
thoia: Enterprise
Wintergoblin: Enterprise
solove: Enterprise
JeremyVS: Enterprise, because it's far too easy to take out the shield generators on an SD.
Ebonwoulfe: Enterprise, but the Star Destroyer would kill at least one extra
AlorielLelyn: That's like asking if a battleship can defeat a PT boat. ISDs are about 1.5 miles in length and have a crew of thousands. The Enterprise D was perhaps .5 miles in length at most, and had a crew of about 1500. Rather like modern carriers. No comparison in firepower or ability.
shippert: Heck, it's gotta be harder to destroy a star than one silly spaceship
tragicpoet: Star Destroyer, enterprise is fake
Scott Firestone IV: Star Destroyer
bucklen_uk: Don't know, don't care
gnomehome: Really don't care.
Belash: Star Destroyer
berserkley: Enterprise
StormKnight: Enterprise. Unless Vader is on the Star Destroyer.
viogression: Star Destroyer
GuyHill: star destroyer
Blackwind: Star Destroyer
Nightmare: Liberator
DangerMouse: I'm thinking the Star Destroyer, although you can never count out the Enterprise with Capt. James T. Kirk at the helm.
djlg: The Box Office
P.O.G.G.: probably the Star Destroyer
Steve Leach: Star Destroyer of course!
Ludocrazy: Enterprise
geberus: Star Destroyer
Mike A: I'd say Star Destroyer, but after that whole twice-repeated Death Star debacle...
netfilterz: Star Destoryer, but only because it has fighter cover. Without the TIE fighters the Enterprise would win, because it has a technological advantage...
chaddyboy_2000: I hope they both blow up.
nm156: Star Destroyer
PghArch: Enterprise, 'cause they're the good guys.
BobDodgerBlue: Star Destroyer
dietevil: I think the Star Destroyer, but I would need to know their relative sizes and whether the tractor beam could drag the enterprise.
louiseh: Who cares?
tp_ryhansen: None of them. They don't exist.
sdownin: Star Destroyer. Just from the number of lasers alone....
jens_hoppe: Star Destroyer
Flyspeck23: Star Destroyer.
Shakar: Star Destroyer.
Glamorous Mucus: You must be joking. One of these ships is called "Star Destroyer." The other is controlled by a fat infantile Esperanto-intoning lounge singer wearing a leotard with no pockets.
djflippy: Star Destroyer
wtrollkin2000: Enterprise (I'm guessing any civ that can invent matter transporters and kill the entire surface population with phaser strikes is above the other. Plus The Empire needs to land ground troops and ordinance on the surface to do anything. And the deathstar is just lame.)
ValJor: If we are talking about destructive power, the Star Destroyer, of course. But if Kirk is on board, he would easily defeat the other captain by talking so much that the other guy would die of boredom.
CDRodeffer: Star Destroyer
jdroscha: Star Destroyer
snoozefest: what's star destroyer?
Denise: What's a Star Destroyer?
jttm: Star Destroyer
skelebone: Star Destroyer -- it's hugeified.
ynnen: Star Destroyer -- if the damn thing could aim. The scarier question: Red Shirt Ensigns vs. Stormtroopers.
manowarplayer: Star Destroyer
CortexBomb: The Enterprise, if only because Star Detroyers always end up getting mangled in the end while the Enterprise can even survive crash landings on planetary surfaces...